This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

It’s not all hiking and bungee jumping down under

Dr Kate Harding

200x200 dr kate harding pic cut out duo

Not a day goes by now that I have returned to the UK that I don’t think of Northland, the glorious top chunk of the North Island of New Zealand where I lived and worked for just under two years. While my work there as a GP was in many ways similar to that in the UK, I found the patients presented some unique and unexpected challenges.

For one thing, the area is not known for the rude health of its inhabitants. Many Northlanders are grossly overweight, their rates of diabetes and renal failure are sky-high, they have appalling diets, and the socio-economic profile of the region has traditionally been dire – though an influx of wealthy retiree Aucklanders is beginning to change that.

New Zealand is the third fattest country in the world. Drug and alcohol use are common. Domestic violence is too. Housing is often inadequate, with poor or no heating, and damp and mould are a real issue, especially for those with asthma and chronic illnesses of every kind. Public transport is patchy, and non-existent in rural areas, and car dependency is therefore high.

As in the UK, the gap between rich and poor is alarming, and widening all the time. The rich live exceptionally well in New Zealand; the poor are shockingly poor.

Other presentations took me aback - impetiginous ‘school sores’ are everywhere

All of this came as a surprise to me, and could not be further from the image of the active, lean hikers and bungee-jumpers seen in the country’s very successful tourism campaigns in recent years. (Such types do exist, of course - I was married to one - but are, for obvious reasons, rarely seen inside a doctor’s surgery!)

On the plus side, New Zealand is famously one of the most beautiful countries in the world. The coastal scenery in Northland is second to none – the beaches glisten in the sunshine, virtually empty, fringed by Pohutukawa trees, the Kiwi ‘Christmas trees’ which flame red over the winter months and are celebrated in thousands of Instagram posts each year. Community spirit is alive and well and actively cultivated, and people are down-to-earth, kind, warm and funny (until they step into their cars, that is – but that is a rant for another day.) Maori culture is valued, as opposed to being suppressed, as it was in the past (though it is fair to say that racism remains common, particularly in its subtler, more insidious forms).

Day to day, the conditions I saw in surgery were in many ways familiar to me. We served a largely elderly, affluent population, on the usual modern-day mix of statins, cardiac drugs, inhalers, creams, bisphosphonates, and supplements of every kind – the Antipodean love affair with naturopathy is an enduring one.

Other presentations took me aback. Skin conditions are rife. Impetiginous ‘school sores’ are everywhere. Kids go barefoot at the drop of a hat (keep in mind that mud and rain are a major part of Northland life, where it pours heavily for much of the winter) and are positively encouraged to kick their shoes off on arrival at school. Football is played barefoot, leading to completely avoidable injuries, and penetration injuries are common. Cross-country running is also done without shoes. After just a month in New Zealand my son’s feet (to which I had never needed to pay a moment’s attention) were covered in scars, scratches, running sores and a crop of veruccas that proved resistant to all treatments known to man.

Sore throats are brought immediately to medical attention, often within hours, following a vigorous public health campaign attempting to wipe out rheumatic fever. (Yes – rheumatic fever. In many ways, Northland has more in common with its Pacific Island neighbours that with, say, the South Island of New Zealand.) I spent much of my day swabbing them, accordingly, somewhat bewildered to hear, yet again, the words ‘yes, this came on today, doctor. I knew you’d want to see me straight away’.

My previous experience of working in New Zealand had been in Dunedin, at Otago University’s student health centre, some years ago now, and Whangarei might as well be in a different country. Dunedin is Scottish in feel, and cosmopolitan due to its large university. It is famous for its albatrosses and its penguins. Fleeces abound there, and craft beer outlets have colonised its streets.

Northland is different in every way. It is brighter, more colourful; it is hotter, and poorer. It is rougher around the edges. It has considerable charm. It consumes a LOT of fried chicken. I love them both. I miss New Zealand. But, for now, I belong back in Britain.

Dr Kate Harding is a locum GP and hospice doctor in Herefordshire

Rate this article  (4.59 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (4)

  • I love your blogs!! keep them coming!!
    thank you for sharing!

    - anonymous salaried!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I lived and worked all over NZ for 20 years . I am currently back in my native scotland but looking forward to returning to my second country, New Zealand , in a few years time.
    I was very pleased to read your Blog which reflects a lot more of the truth of NZ rather than the glossy reports from many of our colleaques. These tend to be written by those who merely touched the surface of good weather and outdoor pursuits.

    Well done for being more thoughtful and truthful. If you think the incidence of Strep and other disesases of poverty are bad in Northland you should see the Aboriginal parts of Outback Australia- Truly Third World

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hi Christine, Katharine Phelan here! If you would like to get in touch I'm still at the surgery in Mauchline or via my website
    I also enjoy these posts as I do wonder what working life in OZ and NZ would have been like. Some things are better and some are worse. I had no idea there was a big barefoot culture and that rheumatic fever was still a major health problem.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Kate Harding

    Thanks for your replies! I have yet to work in the Australian Outback, and can only imagine...I have worked in Brisbane and Perth, but, as you know, you could live in such cities for months at a time without even realising that there IS an Aboriginal presence in the country at all. In Perth I was dealing with hair analysis results, naturopath 'referrals' and whatever the current now ubiquitous 'adrenal fatigue' used to present as in the mid- 2000's - I have thankfully forgotten! But I had friends who did work in Aboriginal health clinics on the city outskirts, and their stories were absolutely hair-raising. Like you, I hope to return Down Under in due course - at least for a chunk of the year. I will forever have my heart divided between the two hemispheres, I think!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say