This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

To tackle obesity, start with children

Dr Katie Musgrave

Will children born today have the highest rates of obesity the UK has ever seen?

I’m no public health expert, but it seems obvious that the most effective approach to tackling this health crisis would be to start with children. My understanding is that once fat cells are laid down, their numbers remain constant throughout life. Friends and family who have struggled with weight issues from childhood, have almost invariably had a lifelong problem.

Rather than instructing GPs to refer patients to patchy weight management services, and adding another dubious QOF indicator, public health services would be better off looking at educating new parents.

As a mother of three, I’m well-versed in the eating habits of babies and young children. ‘More, Mummy, more!’, is a frequent refrain in my household. I take the approach that sometimes (*read, fairly often*), they do not need more. Take my middle child. She is a four-year-old with an absolutely ferocious appetite. She is not overweight right now, but I have no doubt if she were to determine her portion sizes, she soon would be.

Sending her to preschool, I always endeavour to pack a suitably healthy packed lunch. Nevertheless, I’m frequently advised that I don’t pack enough. She needs three snacks as well as a sandwich - apparently. If I don’t pack at least this much, she tells the staff she is hungry, and is given cheesy biscuits. This child has a larger packed lunch than I do.

Another observation I have is of the deeply-held belief that it’s not possible to give a baby or toddler too much healthy food. My sister - a science graduate who prides herself on being well-informed about all matters of child-rearing - has confidently informed me several times of this fact. Consequently, she provides her very young daughter with what appears to me to be an absolute mountain of ‘healthy’ food. There are pitta breads, cheese chunks, cucumber, carrot sticks, hummus and yoghurt dip coming out of this child’s ears.

I’ve heard my sister’s statement repeated multiple times from various well-educated sources. Can it have any truth in it? Surely, as a species, we have not evolved to be provided with unlimited nourishment, regardless of our activity levels? Haven’t we been designed to go through spells of hunger, whilst we hunt or forage for food?

The NHS can ill afford to tiptoe around these issues: when the burden of increased health costs affects the whole system

Finally, there is the tendency for modern parents to have ‘snacks’ on them at all times. If you go to a play centre, park or zoo, you’ll see parents handing out little bags of breadsticks or crisps, Tupperware pots filled with fruit or raisins. These are not mealtimes. The parents themselves will claim: ‘He gets so hungry, if he doesn’t get his snack, he has the most almighty meltdowns’. This may be true, but it’s also true that in the UK one in three children will leave primary school overweight or obese. These children are being given too much food; there is no escaping this fact.

So, how do we begin to unpick this culture of overeating in our schools and childcare settings, not to mention family homes?

My approach would be to educate parents early - as early as prenatal classes - around baby food and portion sizes. Repeat the lessons frequently, and educate nursery, pre-school, and primary school staff. Show parents and carers images of a healthy-sized child at different ages. Many healthy children would appear very slim to modern eyes, with visible ribs and skinny legs.

It would be helpful to show images of an overweight baby, how they progress to be an overweight child, and then an overweight adult, with all the associated health complications. Our society’s visual understanding of a ‘normal’ or ‘healthy’ weight has been hugely distorted by exposure to a generation of over-fed children.

Public health interventions need to identify those children at risk of becoming overweight or obese, offering support early. Parents need to be given clear and uncompromising guidance on how to make healthier choices, and the serious consequences of not changing their behaviours. This is not about stigmatising these families. These children may suffer a lifetime of increased disability, reduced life opportunities, and many will die decades earlier than they would have otherwise. The NHS can ill afford to tiptoe around these issues: when so many will suffer so considerably, and the burden of increased health costs affects the whole system.

We are an obese nation, who eat too much, and move too little. Our health authorities seem too concerned about causing potential offence, to give unambiguous advice to parents and carers who are overfeeding their children. Hencewith, I have no confidence that the UK’s obesity crisis will have improved in twenty years’ time.

In the meantime, my sister continues to load her daughter’s plate with food. Perhaps I should feed back on the outcome here in 2038? However, by then it be too late, for yet another generation.

Dr Katie Musgrave is a GP trainee in Plymouth and quality improvement fellow for the South West

Rate this article  (2.56 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (11)

  • Until the fat doctors and nurses sort themselves out you are not going to 'educate' anyone. Fatness (as a problem) is entirely subjective. The consultation has become so repeatedly tiresome it is no longer worth the effort; chuck them in for another futile ride on the 'Weight Management' carousel.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The medical profession and the food industry have been pushing ‘low fat diet’ for thirty to forty years I.e ‘high carb/sugar. It will take some time to reverse!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Fat smoking nurses

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There is money to be made in obesity...from cereals, to diets, to clothes, to instagrammers, to gyms, to angiograms, to insulin, to counselling. Who truly wants this planet to be healthy and compassionate? Children follow adults and marketing companies follow children.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • there is a more important issue which is about improving preconceptual health and wellbeing if we really want to reduce the obesity epidemic.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There is generally luck of prevention programmes in UK, too much sugary and processed food in diet, also when you look what children have as school meal mostly processed food, no wonder there is high obesity in children, this is were it all starts, also you nearly feel guilty if you want to take lunch break because you have to work, people are like slaves in most jobs eating by computer, until society changes nothing will change

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • its all about economics and making a profit out of human dna to store fat in case of famine. fat people die younger so less pension costs. you want to stop obesity - ban all processed foods and imports, create a designed en masse famine, we only eat what we can grow. aint gonna happen though.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • “I am no Public Health expert”

    Quite: , and to write a lot about your family squabbles, while ignoring the crucial role of physical activity and the need for daily sports in school age children is pretty sad.

    This piece is neither informative nor amusing.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • @keitflyer- Public Health Experts are failing so why can't Katie have a go? She is absolutely right re snacks- the French do not offer them to children, they give them meals, and their obesity rates are lower. I see kids every day, dozens, walking to school drinking high carb energy drinks and eating chocolate. Sometimes the morons in society just need to be shamed in to action.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • d in vadar | Locum GP17 Jul 2020 12:25pm
    "ban all processed foods and imports" - shows you don't know your history, as Prohibition worked a "treat", didn't it? :) Sausages and mince going "underground" now? A designed en masses famine? Oh, you mean like the communists/Stalinists, Maoists, and current South African govt did and are doing? What are you going to do with those who disagree? Gulags?

    WhoamI | Locum GP21 Jul 2020 2:24pm
    Shaming works to some extent, but the PHE are not failing because they are crap, they are failing because they have to work against a system designed to make them fail, i.e a system that disincentivises personal responsibility. The left hand says eat/drink less tasty sweet things so it doesn't make you fat. The right hand says, but if you do get fat, we'll cover all your medical costs, employment costs, social costs, etc. Why would people "suffer/restrict their choices", if they pay no price for not doing so?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say