This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Putting GPs in gyms is a fantasy – and a fallacy

Dr Ellie Cannon

dr ellie cannon 3 x 2

Apparently we’re all going to the gym. Not to de-stress after a day in clinic, but to see patients, as ‘leading health experts’ have claimed GPs should be stationed in gyms to tackle our pervasive obesity crisis and send people into Zumba classes. 

The Royal Society of Public Health has called for this ground-breaking measure to persuade patients to sign up on the spot for exercise classes, and hand out prescribed exercise plans to gym goers or those afraid of working out.

What with the sugar tax arrival, Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall’s Fat Fight and the constant barrage of pseudo-scientific celeb diet advice, this was just another headline that had my eyes rolling.

I was left wondering if ‘leading health experts’ have ever actually set foot in a GP surgery or witnessed a 10-minute GP consultation. Or in fact taken the time to understand the complexities behind the obesity crisis and those it typically affects.

This shows a total lack of understanding of the multiculturalism, deprivation and socio-economic strata GPs bear witness to

Not to mention the fact that right now, we don’t have enough GPs actually in GP surgeries, never mind any spare to put in the local gym.

The trouble with all these ‘radical’ obesity measures that GPs are supposed to adopt and commend is they don’t reflect real life: often the organisations proposing them are single-focus bodies (the gym idea came from Ukactive) who lack the pragmatism that health professionals, particularly GPs, have developed through dealing with actual patients and their complex lives and risk factors.

My patients who are suffering and ill as a result of their obesity are not going to pop to see me before Body Combat, because they are not in the gym. Gyms are full of a certain sector of society that generally excludes those in the grips of this obesity epidemic. Gyms can be incredibly daunting places for people to attend, whether to see your GP or anyone else.

I also totally resent the notion that gyms hold the monopoly on exercise when there are plenty of other (often free) options. It all looks a bit derisorily middle class from where I’m sitting: calling for us to be in gyms shows a total lack of understanding of the multiculturalism, deprivation and socio-economic strata GPs bear witness to.

I like the idea of lifestyle medicine, don’t get me wrong: I am aware that my patients need appropriate diet advice, exercise plans and realistic approaches to suit their lives, families and socio-economic status – but GPs cannot do that. It’s a nice idea. It can’t be done in 10 minutes; we are not trained in diet or exercise and of course, there is still so much else to do.

We have a whole profession of dieticians in this country that we underuse. Not celeb foodies or nutritionists, but NHS dieticians who are experts in nutrition, food and weight loss. Yet dietary advice is more and more confined to secondary care and very little is available for the community. If experts were to acknowledge the truly far-reaching aetiology of the obesity epidemic, we would have hundreds of dieticians lined up for primary care weight loss strategies. Sadly, none of the weight loss pilot schemes where I work were ever recommissioned.

Admittedly amongst the usual high-profile voices, celebrity chef Jamie Oliver has called for an environmental and multi-pronged approach to obesity to tackle the whole environment we are subjected to: the food industry, education, advertising and government need to be taken to task. This is more realistic and reflects Sir Michael Marmot’s conclusions: that health inequalities arise from a complex interaction of many factors and we need action across all social determinants of health. Society needs changing as well as the individual in their consultation with their GP.

While I was driving to clinic the other morning, I heard a doctor promoting the idea that children need to eat vegetables to battle obesity, suggesting with each meal parents get out the star charts and ensure consumption of a rainbow of colours. What do you do for indigo the presenter asked? You can buy purple sweet potatoes of course.

Exercise opportunities and good food should be there for all but that does not equate to telling everyone to eat organic black quinoa and take up HIIT. It means adopting the principles of Marmot: for all families to allow their children to grow up healthily means creating an environment for them where good food is accessible, bad food is avoidable, exercise is a necessity and the health landscape changes along with the individual. That will not happen by asking me to work in a gym.

Dr Ellie Cannon is a portfolio NHS GP in London and broadcast media doctor   

Rate this article  (4.88 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (11)

  • I totally agree, the notion that we should abandon our surgeries already crammed full of the woes and illnesses if everyday Gp and relocate to a gym to pander to a subsection of society who already are aware and acting on their fitness concerns is ludicrous
    This smacks of the inverse care law that Jim McCormick taught about us about all those years ago in Tcd community health in Dublin
    Read the tyranny of health by his friend Petr Skabanek and I think you will see how far we have strayed from the ideals and goals of our medical predecessors

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • MyBad

    A really intelligent article

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • sounds like a nice way to spend a Monday morning/Friday afternoon. Wonder what my partners will think?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Coalfacegp- Are you a Trinity man also?
    Skrabanek was a great loss but I still go back to his books to stiffen my spine against the health NAZis

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Yes Skrabanek was way ahead of his time and this sort of nonsense would have amused him no end....
    DrDeath is a lovely nome de plume and I am jealous of your monicker
    Another great read was “the doctor, father figure or plumber?”. I don’t know where Gp is heading these days with all the announcements that we are the answer to all societal woes but I reckon our teachers would have loved the challenge to criticise and question all of the nonsense being peddled as science when in reality they are pseudo science at best!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Really well written and comprehensive article! I’d never really rated Dr Cannon ( only seen daily mail stuff and was a bit dubious)- but this is excellent- I now hold u in high regard and can see why you’re in the daily mail- for a sensible voice to get the nesssge out to the many - wee fine- keep going!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Well done and well said

    Anonymous salaried!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What a well written article

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ned Diddly Diddly

    There is a spectrum of gyms
    from luxury David Lloyd types
    to more basic puregym types

    NHS Staff would really appreciate a free gym membership or a discounted one
    as the artice states it helps to destress
    (better than colouring books)

    Some of the newer flashy Health centres
    already have a gym on one level
    patients love them and all age types attend
    Having similar patients there makes it less threatening

    Elderly used to have free swimming

    if its there and its free
    people will use it

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ned Diddly Diddly

    For Kids
    Annoyingly lots of gyms do not allow kids
    (insurance reasons??)
    Free sports groups for kids
    scouts groups etc
    First try pulling them away from the TV or consoles
    (shut down times)

    Healthier food is often more expensive
    or less appealing...
    Don't buy sugary bad foods in first place

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say