This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pulse june2020 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

The waiting game

Typhoid Mary: a 21st century perspective

Dr David Mummery

Here’s a little tale about Typhoid Mary.

Mary Mallon was born in Ireland in 1869, migrating to the US to become a cook for affluent New York families. Described as being in ‘perfect health’, seven of the eight families she worked for were not: they became stricken down with Typhoid fever, including in areas of New York where Typhoid was unheard of.

In late 1906, one family hired a typhoid researcher called George Soper to investigate, and he published his results on June 15th 1907 in JAMA. Soper concluded that Mary Mallon was involved in all the typhoid outbreaks that were recorded during this time. In 1907 she was quarantined, as she was deemed to be a ‘carrier’ by the NYC Health Inspector, and she was forcibly held in isolation at a clinic located at Riverside Hospital, on North Brother Island near the Bronx.

79.7% of individuals who contracted Covid caught it from someone who was asymptomatic

She died on November 11th 1938 at the age of 69 of pneumonia, after nearly three decades of isolation, and she is believed to have infected 51 people in total, three of whom died; she was the first person in the USA identified as an ‘asymptomatic carrier’ of the disease.

What has this got to do with anything? It was interesting to note that in the latest research from Wuhan, China where the current pandemic originated, it is thought that 79.7% of individuals who had contracted coronavirus had caught it from someone who was asymptomatic.

Therefore, when I read the NHS England guidance that, in some instances, the 1.5m very high risk ‘shielded’ patients may be seen by ‘routine home visits’ – depending on the local model – if needed, I did a double take.

Surely the whole point of shielding is that this very vulnerable group are trying to protect themselves from infection, or coming into contact with someone who may be infected and transmit the virus onto them? But which group may be more likely than average be exposed to repeated viral loads and be harbouring and possibly onwardly transmitting viral contagion onto others, despite themselves having no symptoms? Of course, it is healthcare workers, including GPs.

So as we GPs ponder NHSE’s instruction for us to do home visits on the 1.5 million very vulnerable ‘shielded’ group of patients, the tragic tale of ‘Typhoid Mary’ should possibly slightly impinge on our consciousness, as we decide whether to accede and accept this NHSE advice and request.

NHSE, have you heard about things called ‘video’ and ‘telephone’ consultations? They are quite popular at the moment.

It would be very unfortunate if we become known at the ‘Covid-19 GPs’ by subsequent generations of our profession.

Dr David Mummery is a GP in west London and academic clinical research fellow at Imperial College London

Rate this article  (4.83 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (2)

  • Almost everything that comes out of NHSE is tainted with politics and should be ignored by anyone with even a hint of scientific training.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Maybe NHSE should speak to an epidemiologist before issuing such a dangerous decree. Thankfully GPs have the sense not to list to such ridiculous dictats.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say