This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Our ’appy new minister deserves a digital response


copperfield duo 1500x1000px

So now we know what the future holds. Because we have a new health secretary, called Matt Hancock, and this new health secretary has his own social media app, called Matt Hancock.

Which seems to confirm what everyone is saying about him – specifically, that ‘He’s really into digital.’ Yes, go ahead and snigger, but this actually means – unamusingly – that he’s both tech-savvy and a technophile.

That is presumably why the politician with the app has registered with the practice with the app, GP at Hand. So everyone is ’appy. Except me, of course.

True, a future of virtual consultations and AI GP chatbots comes as no great surprise. The digital engine has been running for a while, and now we have the driver. ‘Hold onto your hats. Resistance is futile, it’s the direction of travel,’ we are told.

Open the floodgates with a 24/7 tech service inviting symptoms-for-fun and I predict a system crash

But you’d expect me, a geriatrique terrible, to hate the idea of a digital future, and I do. And you’d expect me to rant about it, so I will.

Take the supposedly unstoppable force that is AI. Anyone who believes the consultation can be reduced to ‘input data/follow algorithm/output diagnosis/suggest treatment’ is conceding they know jack-shit about general practice. I’d estimate only about 5% of consultations follow such a simple linear narrative, yet I’m guessing that they’re the sort featured in AI consult-offs against real doctors.

The reality of most consultations is multiple symptoms, non sequiturs, irrelevant distractions and anxiety as cause or effect. Only a minority end with a clear diagnosis and that’s not because GPs are stupid, but because they are clever, and realise you can’t reduce chaos to a one-word output. After all, sometimes the ‘patient’ isn’t even the patient – such as the depressed and desperate mum repeatedly making unnecessary appointments for her sniffly child. Good luck with that, AI.

Besides, most symptoms are harmless, self-limiting and never get as far as a medical opinion simply because they don’t need one. Open the floodgates with a 24/7, all-you-can-eat tech service inviting symptoms-for-fun and I predict a system crash that will not be solved by switching it off and on again.

Seriously: just because there’s a workforce crisis coinciding with a medico-technological revolution doesn’t automatically mean one can solve the other. If you’re not convinced, just think of 10 of your most complex, poly-symptomatic, demanding patients, and how you try to help them while limiting the collateral damage. And then imagine what havoc they could wreak on a digital system, and vice versa.

It’s horrific and demeaning seeing technology masquerading as progress and convenience, reducing our profession from art to pseudoscience. The great and good GPs commemorated on the NHS’s 70th birthday must be turning in their graves. They deserve better. So do we, and so do our patients.

So if I can figure out how to download Matt Hancock’s Matt Hancock app, I will give a response. Yes, that response will be digital - and yes, that does mean two fingers.

Dr Tony Copperfield is a GP in Essex 



Rate this article  (4.87 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (6)

  • Genius!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Perhaps the best synopsis of the current idiocy that is going on I’ve read

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • David Banner

    Patient - “so you see, I have this pain, well it’s more of a funny feeling really, in my left arm. It’s always one side of my body......”
    Robodoc - “does not compute”
    Patient - “...then there’s my fuzzy head, Doreen says she gets it too, but only on Tuesdays.....”
    Robodoc - “does not compute”
    Patient - “....and I’m a martyr to my fibro, not that Dr Bloggs ever took me seriously....”
    Robodoc - “does not compute. Error. Error.”
    Patient -“.....and this rash hasn’t gone....well it has today, but last week it was......”
    Robodoc -“Error. Error. Initiating auto destruct in 10 seconds. 10,9,8,7......”

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree with Northwestdoc

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • David Banner 1.02pm

    Spot on.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Brilliant! But it gets worse. As more and more "patients" access care with lower and lower acuity the GP workforce crunch will arrive at the digital buffers. Where on earth are the GPs needed for this bonkers scheme going to come from. PS...evidence based policy making my ****!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say