This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Mr Hunt, who are you to disagree with Stephen Hawking?

Dr Kailash Chand

Dear Mr Hunt, with which part of this statement by Stephen Hawking do you disagree?

'The NHS is in a crisis, and one that has been created by political decisions, these political decisions include underfunding and cuts, privatising services, the public sector pay cap, the new contract imposed on junior doctors, and removal of the student nurses’ bursary. Political decisions such as these cause reductions in care quality, longer waiting lists, anxiety for patients and staff, and dangerous staff shortages. Failures in the system of privatised social care for disabled and elderly people have placed an additional burden on the NHS.’

I could add many more to this list since you took over as health secretary from Andrew Lansley.

You have overseen the worst crisis in the history of the service and demoralised a generation of doctors. Since you became health secretary in September 2012, you have been misusing statistics as a way to impose the new junior doctor contract and, in doing so, you have misled the public and parliament.

Your statements about mortality and seven-day working in the NHS simply didn’t stack up. You have been economical with the truth by repeatedly attributing excess deaths to doctors not being available at weekends. I have no doubt that if you were a doctor you would be facing disciplinary action for your misinterpretation of data, and the impact it has had on patient care.

You were appointed by former Prime Minister David Cameron to detoxify Andrew Lansley’s reforms and keep the NHS out of the headlines. But your confrontational style has achieved the reverse. Under your watch, trolley waits in A&E are almost five times higher than in 2010, and timely access to primary care has become difficult if not impossible in many areas.

The only ’progress’ you have made in the last four and half years is to turn the NHS into NHS plc, increasingly drawing on public funds to line the pockets of wealthy venture capitalists or multinationals. The NHS, once the envy of the world, is already showing signs of cash fatigue and fragmentation, with no one accepting responsibility. There are 4 million people on NHS waiting lists – presenting a significant proportion of the population with the agonising prospect of waiting in pain.This is the story of your term as health secretary.

Under your stewardship, England’s major A&Es are under record strain with black alerts being regularly sounded, and in some instances wards turning patients away. Last year, the A&E crisis spread to other sectors. The most worrying aspect of your tenure as health secretary is delivering the lowest additional funding increase to the NHS in its history with a knock-on effect on patients in terms of treatment and facilities available. More than 13,000 beds have been closed, cutting the capacity of the NHS by 5 million a year. So bad is the state of affairs in mental health, that nine former health secretaries condemned the Government for failing to live up to its promises on mental health.

A failing NHS will only help to boost private healthcare insurance for those who can afford it, signalling the death knell for a universal healthcare service, free at the point of use. The moment of crisis many of us warned of has arrived and, unfortunately, I have no hope that the NHS can be retrieved from this state of affairs. It’s high time you should go, because the salvation of the NHS is a long-term challenge, and you show no serious commitment to finding long-term solutions. Your actions as health secretary have fallen below the standards one would expect of a health secretary, particularly your use of 'questionable statistics' - rightly highlighted by Stephen Hawking - as the basis for policies, and for 'alienating and decimating' whole branches of the medical profession, ‘such as junior doctors, nurses, consultants, paramedics and GPs’.

Who, other than you and your party, can disagree with Stephen Hawking? As he puts it: 'The NHS is Britain’s finest public service and a cornerstone of our society, something that binds us together. People value the NHS, and are proud that we treat everyone equally when they are sick. The NHS brings out the best in us. We cannot lose it.’

Professor Hawking has given us answers to many of the universe’s most challenging questions, and even he can’t work out why you, Mr Hunt, are still in your job. There is no doubt that you are the worst health secretary in the NHS’s history, and must go!

Dr Kailash Chand is a retired GP from Tameside and is Honorary Vice-President of the BMA

Rate this article  (4.36 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (10)

  • Chand the problem is with the NHS. It cannot last. I don't defend Hunt but until the BMA drops this perverse support NHS at cost of doctors' health approach, nothing will improve. Doctors are leaving the UK because they don't like the NHS system. You never advocate another system yet this is what many of the silent majority want

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree with anon above.
    Communism never works for the professional classes.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Stephen Hawking should stick to physics.Even in that he is not infallible as explained by Prof Leonard Susskind in his book The Black Hole War: My Battle with Stephen Hawking to Make the World Safe for Quantum Mechanics.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment


    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Jeremy Hunt's arrogance comes from the fact that his constituents still voted him in despite his blatant effort to destroy and privatise the NHS. Why would he not think that he's smarter than Stephen Hawking when the British public appear to be idiots?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • David Banner

    The fact that May has kept Hunt in post speaks volumes. Clearly senior Torres think he is doing a brilliant job. The trick has always been how to dismantle the horribly expensive NHS without the public noticing. Hunts fronts up to the media, smugly donning his NHS badge, and sells the slogans of "£8 billion investment", "7 day NHS" and "5000 more GPs" to the gullible. Dissenters are dismissed as lefty alarmists, whilst the real work of starving out GP partnerships, rolling out the red carpet to the private sector, and "rationalising" hospital services via STPs (of which the public seem blissfully unaware) are progressing smoothly in the background.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The NHS is the problem, and the BMA leadership need to become part of the solution if they want to be relevant.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dear Khailash, Like Prof Hawking, you are a long-term Labour supporter.Not a crime in itself (discuss)but its a fair bet that if the Government were handing out chauffeur driven limos to take patients to clinics you would still object to something. NHS "envy of the world"???Never in my 37 years of working in it.If it ever was, why has no other nation copied it?Yes its in a mess,but could that possibly be because we have the wrong model?Why not have a little humility and admit that there could be other ways of making the system work?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • No one else can do the job that MP Jeremy Hunt does, which is why he is in that unique position during such a difficult period.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agrrr entirely. It would ask what does Jeremy Hunt know about Black Holes ?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say