This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Why hold back the tears?

In second place in Pulse’s 2015 writing competition, Dr Ellie Cannon

Where is the line drawn between being yourself and being your doctor-self? Is there a line? Is there a barrier, like a 12-foot impenetrable wall that can’t be scaled, to protect our own emotion and our own weakness?

I have only ever cried in one consultation. I am a sentimental soul – I cry at films, childhood memories, when my kids are sad or ill. I am a crier.

But apparently not when I am at work. I have witnessed a man’s last breath and not cried. I have locked eyes with a 12-year-old patient dying from a brain tumour, and when she asked me if she would die, I didn’t cry. I once delivered a baby on the floor in my GP surgery: a healthy perfect baby whose accidental early arrival brought my waiting room to tears. My heart raced for days but I didn’t cry. I have seen fragile babies bruised from child abuse and felt irate, but never cried.

umbrella 460x260

So why do I now sit in front of Derek and struggle to hold back the tears? He is worn out by COPD; the inhalers give little comfort. He has been thrown out by his wife and he is homeless, sleeping in a garage near what used to be his home. He is working, but he can’t afford rent and the housing department is not interested in him.

There appears to be no way out of the situation, no path for us to forge even together to pull him from despair, no way to tackle the idiocy of a social system that has left a working man homeless. I have a fleeting thought of giving him money but it passes. So I am left with nothing for him. No flash of idea. No golden ticket. All I offer him are my tears.

I’m not sure I will ever know why I cried in that consultation. Possibly it was the desperation we felt, my own sense of powerlessness or inadequacy.

Perhaps I wasn’t crying for Derek at all.

Perhaps I was selfishly crying for myself and the realisation that I too am weak, and I can’t always help people.

Perhaps I cried as the remnants of any faith I may have had ebbed away. 

Maybe my tears belied the immense responsibility of being the only human this man had to hear him.

It changes you to cry in a consultation. It changes your position and role in that clinic room when you sit proudly as a professional, as a rock, as someone in control.

That is a good thing. It opened up a vulnerability I was always aware I had in my personal life, but which we all try to mask at work.

And I learned there is no wall. There is no barrier for me. Most of the time it will appear to be there – the fence will seem high.

But deep down there is no difference between who I am, and who I am as a doctor.

Dr Ellie Cannon is a GP in London and a columnist for the Mail on Sunday and Woman magazine.

<<< More from Pulse’s Writing Competition 2015

Rate this article  (4.2 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (4)

  • Not impressed.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • That is a beautiful piece, thank you. I am also a crier, and can relate to this very well.

    Good on ya!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I don't think this gives us any new insights whatsoever and I agree unimpressive

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Great insight! rare to see that in a GP. Well done for opening up. We need more GPs like you and not those selfish, cold-hearted, greedy and soulless pigs that call themselves doctors.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say