One in three GP requests to close practice lists blocked by NHS England
Exclusive GP practices are facing uncontrollable ‘severe workload pressures’ as area team managers have refused 23 out of 78 requests for a temporary list closure in 2013, a rise of ten percentage points on the proportion refused permission the year before.
Pulse has learnt that the 27 area teams rejected 30% of GP practice requests for temporary list closure in 2013, compared with 20% of requests in 2012.
NHS England said the rise in refusals was due to area teams applying a ‘single approach’, compared with the variable approach taken by PCTs in 2012. But the GPC said that rising numbers of applications should be an ‘alarm bell’ for NHS England and that huge variations in rejection rates in different areas of the country showed that a more ‘consistent approach’ was needed.
The figures - obtained under the Freedom of Information Act - show that in the London and south of England region over half (53%) of list closure requests were denied in 2013, compared with 30% in the north of England and 16% in the Midlands and east.
The statistics also indicated an increasing number of applications from GP practices to close their lists, with figures from the 14 area teams able to provide comparative statistics showing the number of applications rose from 40 to 48 from 2013 to 2012.
NHS England said the rise in refusals was due to a national policy it introduced in July last year. The Government abolished a previous system where GPs could say their list was ‘open but full’ from April 2012, and since then approval by the local commissioning body is necessary for a practice to close its list.
A spokesperson said: ‘Whilst the circumstance for a practice wishing to close its list will be local for each case, the policy describes a single approach for all 27 area team, compared to 152 PCT operating models that existed prior to establishing NHS England.
‘Together these two changes provide a clearer, more detailed process to ensure applications for list closure are applied more consistently and this is likely to be the key driver for any change in the outcome of applications between 2012 and 2013.’
How rising numbers of list closure request are being knocked back
Of which refused
|London and the South||17||9||53%|
|Midlands and East||31||5||16%|
|North of England||30||9||30%|
Of which refused
|London and the South||12||1||8%|
|Midlands and East||4||2||50%|
|North of England||24||5||21%|
Source: FOI request to NHS England
But GPC deputy chair Dr Richard Vautrey said rising applications should set off ‘alarm bells ringing’ at NHS England about rising practice workload.
He said: ‘Practices do not do this lightly and it is often a sign of severe workload pressures often created by a workforce crisis in the practice. Area teams should be taking a consistent approach and if there is regional variation NHS England should be taking steps to resolve this and ensure practices across England are dealt with in a fair way and in line with national standards.’
He added: ‘Whilst the numbers are small these figures show in increase in the number of practices seeking to close their list. This is very worrying and could be another alarm bell ringing which provides further evidence that practice workload pressures have reached crisis point.’
RCGP council member Dr Una Coales said she had heard of practices where doctors now covered more than twice as many patients as they typically had. She added: ‘This is dangerous as a sick child or adult may not get a timely appointment.’
A spokesperson for NHS England London region said: ‘There is an NHS England national policy covering the temporary closure of practice lists, and the London region follows this. There is a requirement to set up a local panel to make these decisions, which again makes decision based on the national policy.’
How to apply to close your list
The application must include:
- options the practice has considered, rejected or implemented in an attempt to relieve the difficulties encountered about its open list and, if any of the options were implemented, the level of success in reducing or extinguishing such difficulties;
- any discussions between the practice and its patients and a summary of them, including whether those patients believe the list of patients should or should not be closed;
- any discussions between the practice and other contractors in the practice area and a summary of the opinion of the other practices as to whether the list of patients should or should not be closed;
- the period of time during which the practice wishes its list of patients to be closed must be more than three months and up to 12 months;
- any reasonable support from the area team that the practice considers would enable its list of patients to remain open or for the period of proposed closure to be minimised;
- any plans the practice has to alleviate the difficulties mentioned in that application while the list of patients is closed so the list can reopen at the end of the proposed closure period without such any other information the practice considers ought to be drawn to the attention of the area team.