This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

BMA declares it has no confidence in the GMC

UK doctor leaders have supported a vote of no confidence in the GMC following the controversial court case involving Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba.

The BMA's Annual Representative Meeting voted in favour of a motion declaring ‘that it has no confidence in the GMC as a professional regulatory body’.

ARM delegates also carried a part of the motion calling for ‘a public inquiry to review the GMC’s conduct in the Bawa-Garba case’.

But they opposed calls for GMC chief executive Charlie Massey and chairman Sir Terence Stephenson to resign. 

They also opposed ‘legislative changes to make sure that the Government, and not the profession, funds the GMC’.

Proposing the motion, Dr Krishna Kasaraneni, the BMA’s GP Committee workforce lead, said: ‘We can all relate to working in an environment where there simply aren't enough hours in the day to do justice to every single one of our patients.

‘When faced with what seems like impossible situations, what doctors, particularly junior doctors need, is a helping hand - not threats of a criminal prosecution.’

GP leaders attending this year's LMCs Conference also declared a vote of no confidence in the GMC, on the same grounds.

LMC leaders also called on the BMA to advise GPs to 'disengage from written reflection in both appraisal and revalidation’ until new safeguards are put in place.

Since then, the Government has declared its intention to strip the GMC of its right to appeal fitness-to-practise rulings by its own tribunal.

While no speakers opposed the no confidence motion, the delegates heeded opposition to calls for the GMC’s chief executive Charlie Massey and chairman Sir Terence Stephenson to resign.

Dr Jenny Vaughan, a representative from the consultants’ conference, said: ‘I think GMC leadership shouldn't resign. They should sort out the mess they've created and also we can only do that - by funding the GMC we actually hold them more accountable.

‘Turn it over to the politicians and the public purse you just won't get that.’

BMA chair Dr Chaand Nagpaul said: ‘I think it's worth reminding ourselves that if we really want to fix a harrowing climate of blame in the NHS, we also have to fix a multiplicity of factors that occurred and proceeded the GMC's intervention.

‘It starts at the fact that we don't have a system that considers system factors, pressures and failing in the workplace and at the first stage that did not happen and the trust was not held to account.’

He added: ‘We don't have confidence in the consistency in the criterion of a criminal prosecution of GNM and it actually raised the whole question of whether a court can judge complex medical situations without training and understanding of human factors.’

The vote of no confidence in the GMC was carried by a margin of 186 votes.

The motion in full

Motion by the agenda committee (to be proposed by Sheffield division): That this meeting, in view of the widespread concerns about the adverse effects of the General Medical Council’s actions in the Bawa-Garba case and its impact on NHS culture and morale:-

i) declares that it has no confidence in the GMC as a professional regulatory body;

ii) demands an apology from the GMC over its handling of that case;

iii) calls upon the Chief Executive and Chairman of GMC to resign;

iv) directs the BMA to seek legislative changes to make sure that the government, and not the profession funds the GMC;

v) calls for a public inquiry to review the GMC’s conduct in the Bawa-Garba case.

Source: BMA

Readers' comments (26)

  • Well done

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • THIS HAS BECOME A "NASTY AND THUGGISH" COUNTRY.
    THE GMC ARE SIMPLY GROSSLY OVERPAID "GOVERNMENT ENFORCERS".
    LOOK AT THE SALARIES AT THE TOP OF THE GMC-THE NUMBERS ARE "SICKENING".
    HOW CAN THOSE WHO EARN SUCH ENORMOUS SALARIES SLEEP AT NIGHT-AFTER "CONSUMING" HUGE INCOMES IN RETURN FOR WHAT SEEMS TO BE "BULLYING GPs".

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Well done BMA. About time. An alternative would be to set up our own "GMC", one that is trusted and works and focused only on medical issues without over bearing regulations undermining doctor's human rights. It cannot be right that as a doctor you have less rights than the average person just by being medically qualified.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Well done. Finally some progress. When can I stop paying my GMC fees? We shouldn't have to pay for them if we have no confidence in them.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Just set up an alternative regulatory body and create competition just like the medical defense unions and give Doctors a choice of whom to Register with.
    Believe me all these nonsense and harassment from GMC will stop.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The GMC is in essence a QUANGO which enforces government policy by diktat. It is registered as a charity, maybe the only example of a charity which funds an arm of government. The profession hold no sway within the GMC, thus it is only logical that as turkeys we should not be paying for Christmas. We will be slaughtered no matter who pays.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The GMC for it's own political and financial reasons, declared and pursued war on the medical profession. End of

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I have NO CONFIDENCE in BMA. They had a nice get together with tea and biscuits and agreed -- "But they opposed calls for GMC chief executive Charlie Massey and chairman Sir Terence Stephenson to resign."
    Haha, Does any one has confidence in BMA?BMA doesnot represent me.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ban the GMC from providing private health insurance to their employees. I strongly object to my fees funding this. Plus it creates a conflict of interest. If GMC employees don't have to use the NHS, then they presumably don't give a stuff if it doesn't function at their hands

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Viva la revolución!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say