This site is intended for health professionals only


Commissioners provide £1m bailout to CCG after influx of Babylon patients



Exclusive Neighbouring CCGs are bailing out Babylon’s NHS host CCG as it struggles to cope financially with the rapid influx of patients.

The Dr Jefferies and Partner GMS practice – which is based within NHS Hammersmith and Fulham CCG – has offered Babylon’s ‘GP at Hand’ service to NHS patients across London since November, which allows them to get an appointment in person on the same or next day and have an online consultation with GPs within minutes.

But the CCG has had to receive funds from elsewhere to cope with the influx of patients, including £800,000 from its neighbour NHS West London CCG, while the North West London Collaboration of CCGs is expecting to provide another £300,000 top-up by the end of this month.

Meanwhile, NHS England’s London regional team has agreed to re-allocate funds from other CCGs across London which are outside of the collaboration.

Under the GP at Hand scheme, patients must deregister with their existing GP practice and Pulse has learned that GP at Hand had signed up over 30,000 patients by the end of last month, with a further 20,000 having applied to join.

But this has come at a cost for NHS Hammersmith and Fulham CCG, which warned in March that it would be £18m short in this financial year unless NHS England agreed to an in-year top-up to its primary care funding allocation.

The North West London Collaboration of CCGs has a ‘risk-sharing’ arrangement in place to transfer contingency funds between members to cover unexpected costs, and its board papers reveal:

  • NHS Hammersmith and Fulham CCG has seen a 10% increase in its registered population as a result of GP at Hand;
  • ‘Financial support’ worth £5m was transfered from the group of CCGs to NHS Hammersmith and Fulham in 2017/18, £800,000 of which was directly related to GP at Hand;
  • The collaboration expects to transfer another £300,000 to the CCG at the end of this month, with further transfers expected during 2018/19;
  • Unlike other transfers via the risk-sharing agreement, GP at Hand-related funds are not re-payable because it ‘relates to a permanent shift of commissioning responsibility’;
  • NHS Hammersmith and Fulham CCG ‘has received confirmation’ that ‘additional costs will be met by NHS England’, and there is ‘an ongoing dialogue’ between the parties ‘to agree the value of the costs attributable to GP at Hand’.

A spokesperson for the North West London Collaboration of CCGs told Pulse: ‘The financial strategy relating to GP at Hand is to reallocate funds as the population transfers registration from other north west London CCGs to Hammersmith and Fulham.

‘The normal NHS allocation process is fixed for 2018/19 and therefore this north west London local arrangement moves the appropriate funding to the CCG as a patient registers with the GP at Hand practice. This should be a cost-neutral process as allocation is shifting in-line with costs.’

Since November, GP at Hand has been signing up patients from across London by making use of the out-of-area registration scheme.

But last month, CCG board papers revealed that one fifth of patients who had signed up from south west London have since re-registered with their original GP practice, prompting complaints from GP leaders regarding the related additional practice workload.

Londonwide LMCs chief executive Dr Michelle Drage said: ‘We hope that this transfer of now over £1m in funding is not to the detriment of practices and patients in the CCG areas losing money.

‘Our interest is in ensuring that patients continue to have access to properly resourced, authentic general practice close to their homes.’

Dr Drage further questioned why the service is being allowed to continue to expand whilst a full evaluation is still outstanding.

She said: ‘This again raises questions about why a service which undermines the financial model of NHS general practice has been permitted to launch without any assessment of its impact on an already cash-strapped system.

‘We hope that the forthcoming independent evaluation will look into the full impact of this model on patients and general practice funding.’

Pulse can also reveal that Ipsos Mori has won the the £250k bid to carry out an independent evaluation of GP at Hand on behalf of NHS Hammersmith and Fulham CCG, which will look at its ‘outcomes and impacts’.

A GP at Hand spokesperson said: ‘The reality is that people across London are exercising their rights to choose their NHS general practice… This, of course, means that Hammersmith and Fulham CCG’s budget will need to increase as they commission services on behalf of more people.

‘Balancing this, CCGs with fewer registered patients going forward will also see changes in their budgets.’

GP leaders have expressed significant concern about the NHS app arguing the service ‘cherry-picks’ fit, young and healthy patients – claims that GP at Hand has refuted.

NHS England London declined to comment.