This site is intended for health professionals only


GPs can refuse to offer patients Covid-19 antibody test, says BMA



Exclusive GPs are not obliged to offer patients Covid-19 antibody testing, the BMA GP Committee has told Pulse.

NHS England had told GPs they could offer the test to any patient who ‘wishes’ to know if they have had the virus, if they are having bloods taken anyway.

NHS England’s letter to GP practices, sent at the end of May, said this had been decided by health secretary Matt Hancock.

But BMA GP Committee chair Dr Richard Vautrey said GPs could use their clinical judgement when deciding whether to offer the test, and there was no obligation to do so.

Some LMCs had already told GPs they could refuse to administer the tests on the basis that the work is currently unfunded.

Asked if GPs could refuse a patient the test, Dr Vautrey said: ‘Yes, it’s not obligatory. You just have to use your clinical judgement as to whether it’s appropriate or not.’

He added: ‘Whenever you’re doing any test, you need to explain what the test is and follow up on the results. So it’s understandable why some practices would want to be cautious about offering the option for such antibody tests.’

And he said practices should not be asked to offer the Covid-19 antibody test to a patient who was not having a blood test for another clinical reason.

He said: ‘There is no clinical benefit of just having an antibody test and we wouldn’t want to see that driving up inappropriate attendance in GP surgeries.’

At the moment, Dr Vautrey said, the only benefit of the antibody test is as ‘a surveillance tool’ which tells you whether the illness you had a few months back was or was not Covid-19.

‘We need to really understand much more about the long-term benefits of having antibody tests other than it being a surveillance tool for public health purposes,’ he said.

Meanwhile, Kent LMC has told local GPs they would support anyone who refused to offer antibody testing.

Its newsletter said: ‘To offer the Covid-19 antibody test to patients already having blood tests for another reason requires counselling, recorded consent and explanation of the result.

‘This constitutes a screening or epidemiological research programme. Other screening programmes are funded by national enhanced services or target payments and research supported by grants and led by relevant organisations and educational institutions.

‘This issue has been raised with the GPC nationally. The potential additional workload this represents is substantial and currently unresourced. Kent LMC will support all GPs who decline to offer Covid-19 antibody testing.’

Dr Yvette Rean, who is a GP in Kent, told Pulse: ‘I’m delighted that the LMC have taken this stance on supporting their local GPs if we decide to refuse widespread/general antibody testing to any patient who requests it.

‘I can see no clincally significant indication where management would be altered from a primary care viewpoint to know what a patient’s Covid-19 antibody status is.

‘I believe it to be academic and useful for data collection and research which although is important, is not in our remit.’

The news comes GPs could be asked to take on live coronavirus testing as NHS England said that swab testing in primary care is the ‘next step’ in the programme.

Related Articles

Honourable mentions

18 September 2020

Some changes to PulseToday

14 September 2020