This site is intended for health professionals only


What patients want



At a medical conference, Edzard Ernst discovers what patients really want from their GP.


For medical conferences, it has become fashionable (and politically correct) to ask patients to present their views. In CAM meetings, this usually entails a patient telling the audience how marvellous her (it usually is a woman) Reiki healer, aromatherapist etc, has been compared to her ghastly experience with mainstream medicine. These lectures are usually loaded with emotion and devoid of anything remotely resembling data, evidence or rational thought. Suffice to say, I find most of them cringingly embarrassing and utterly unhelpful.

Recently, however, I attended a session entitled ‘What Patients Want’ which was scheduled during a large rheumatology meeting. It somewhat changed my mind. There were not one but three patients presenting in succession. All were suffering from chronic rheumatic conditions and all were remarkably rational. Here are some of the recurring themes voiced by them.

Patients want to stay in work and often worry that their condition might prevent them doing so. They are concerned that pain, fatigue, lack of mobility, disability will force them to quit their job. This has more than just financial implications; it importantly impinges on their quality of life and their physical as well as emotional well-being.

Patients also want an early and correct diagnosis so that they can receive the best treatments for their disease. Treating long-term conditions early on, they feel, increases the chances to keep them ‘low key’. Even if that should not be possible, early diagnosis would reduce patients’ suffering. This also means patients want reliable information and easy access to effective therapy.

Patients want a meaningful dialogue with their healthcare team. Good communication within that team is crucially important, they believe. On the part of the doctor, this includes listening to patients and having time to do so. It also means understanding patients’ worries and the fact that information needs to be repeated. What is obvious to us healthcare professionals is often entirely new to patients. To make matters worse, patients are frequently too nervous to take it all in the first time. So repetition is necessary. Finally, a good therapeutic relationship has to give hope and must help patients to cope with their condition.

None of the three patient presenters said ‘we want access to alternative practitioners’. But, it was clear that patients often don’t get what they want from their GP – and this is when they go off and seek it elsewhere, e.g. from CAM practitioners.

Professor Edzard Ernst is professor of complementary medicine at the Peninsula Medical School, University of Exeter.

Click here for more from Edzard Ernst Edzard Ernst