This site is intended for health professionals only


We need support in delivering the antibiotics message



dr zoe norris 200x200px

We can finally see the light at the end of the tunnel of the cough and cold season. It’s been especially nasty this year, and the fact I have at least two patients who ended up being admitted with proper influenza scared me.

Like many of you, I’m sure, I also suffered with the neverending cough, so I’ve been able to sympathise, empathise and catastrophise when patients share their tales of woe.

This doesn’t meant I don’t see a problem in patients consulting with a cough. (My own mum doesn’t believe my protests that I don’t need to see a GP for my cough – despite my being 37 and, you know, a GP myself.)

Every year we try signposting, patient education, delayed scripts, no scripts. We all have our patter for the nasty URTI, and the cough (you know the one: ‘Good news, you don’t need antibiotics and the potential side-effects they bring *cheery smile*! Bad news, there’s not much I can do to make you feel better *sad face*. But here’s a nice leaflet *cheery face again*).

Yet our heroic efforts to put patients off antibiotics are not getting the credit or support they need. Dame Sally Davies, the chief medical officer, has been telling the press that a third of antibiotic prescribing in primary care has no reason attached to it. In other words, when they look at the notes of patients given antibiotics, we’ve either put nothing to explain why we issued them, or something suggesting they weren’t needed. You know the one: ‘Four-day history of dry cough and sore throat. Throat slightly red, chest clear. Amoxicillin 500mg tds issued’.

I accept that sometimes we get this wrong, but we do need a little help every now and again. We can hardly be blamed for the sins of our secondary care colleagues, such as when urology gives every patient C. diff, or when A&E discharge letters bear no resemblance to local guidelines, or when the respiratory clinic asks us to put a patient on a long-term course for its anti-inflammatory effect.

Our heroic efforts to put patients off antibiotics are not getting any credit 

But, above all, the message needs to get through to the public. The campaigning – including those dancing pills – has improved, but no one thinks it applies to them. Why?

Because they feel really ill, because it’s gone on longer than a week, because their sister’s cousin’s friend has the same thing and got antibiotics. The message isn’t getting across in a way patients understand. Handy prescribing guidance, information prescriptions, poster campaigns – all are useless if they don’t make patients stop and realise it means them.

I’m sure if PHE took a few tips from advertising execs we’d be a lot better off. Tesco can persuade me which toilet roll to buy, that I definitely need a sharing pack of chocolate (not to share of course), and that lavender-scented ironing water is essential. Can’t we employ some of these tactics on patients?

So, Dame Sally, instead of pointing out GPs’ foibles – which are not exactly helped by an unmanageable workload – consider how to deliver the message that an individual’s own actions can affect the system as a whole.

Because the current approach just isn’t working. If we’re left flogging ourselves at the coalface with no support, you’re lucky we’re not still using leeches for everything.

Dr Zoe Norris is a GP in Hull. Read more from Norris at pulsetoday.co.uk/norris