This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

GPs to be covered by new 'zero tolerance' policy against abuse from patients

GPs will be protected by a new 'zero tolerance' policy aiming to reduce the number of assaults on NHS staff.

The measures are part of a new violence reduction strategy launched by the Department of Health and Social Care to better protect NHS staff from attacks and abuse.

A new zero-tolerance approach will be adopted and a partnership between the NHS, police and Crown Prosecution Service will aim to see offenders prosecuted quickly.

The strategy, which health secretary Matt Hancock will launch today in a speech at the Royal College of Nursing, will see NHS staff given training on how to deal with a violent situation, and victims of violence will be able to access mental health support.

One in eight NHS employees have experienced violence from patients, their relatives or the public in the past year, which is the highest figure for five years, according to the latest NHS staff survey. 

Going forward, the CQC will scrutinise NHS trusts based on the quality of plans to reduce violence against staff.

Last year, an investigation by Pulse publisher Cogora revealed that two thirds of GPs had experienced some form of abuse from patients.

Mr Hancock said: ‘NHS staff dedicate their lives to protecting and caring for us in our times of greatest need and for any one of them to be subject to aggression or violence is completely unacceptable.’

‘I have made it my personal mission to ensure NHS staff feel safe and secure at work and the new violence reduction strategy will be a key strand of that.’

‘We will not shy away from the issue – we want to empower staff and give them greater confidence to report violence, knowing that they will see meaningful action from trusts and a consistent prosecution approach from the judicial system.’

The new measures follow the Assaults on Emergency Workers (Offences) Bill, which increased the maximum prison sentence for assaulting an emergency worker from six months to a year.

The BMA welcomed the new measures and called for tougher sentences to try and reduce the number of assaults on NHS staff.

BMA junior doctors committee chair, Dr Jeeves Wijesuriya, said: ‘The BMA has long been concerned about the risk and impact of violence on NHS staff and is particularly concerned by the rising numbers of attacks taking place against frontline staff…

‘We believe that tougher sentences for attacks on emergency service workers will make a real difference in reducing the number of serious incidents that staff are subjected to and we support the violence reduction strategy, which sends out a strong deterrent message to those who wilfully assault NHS staff.’

Following a change to the GP contract this year, practices are able to refuse to register patients if they have a violent flag against their record. They can also remove ‘mistakenly registered’ violent patients under the normal procedures.

BMA GP Committee chair Dr Richard Vautrey said: 'GP practice staff are all too often subjected to unacceptable abuse and even attacks from patients who they are trying their best to help.

'As pressures increase within the NHS, with waiting times increasing as practices and hospitals struggle to manage rising workload within inadequate funding, it can be understandable why patients can be frustrated but that can never justify taking that frustration out on those on the frontline trying to care for them. 

'This year we secured improvements to the way the violent patient/safe haven DES operates but there are still too many incidents where commissioners are slow to support practices seeking to take appropriate action when patients overstep the line with their behaviour, and the initiative announced today must address this.'

Readers' comments (17)

  • What happened to the last zero tolerance approach?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This has been rolled out umpteen time over my career and still its the same. boring!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 'maximum prison sentence for assaulting an emergency worker from six months to a year.' should be minimum with no maximum

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Maximum sentence increase is good, but more important is the starting point for sentence. Common assault starting point is community order. For emergency workers it should be the same a assault on police officer; i.e 3 months starting point for sentence. Is this going to happen?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • We are talking about two things here, and the unclear language being used is unhelpful.
    We appear to be talking about zero tolerance for violence and assault; but we should also be talking about zero tolerance (within the GP’s discretion, to allow for upset and reasonable but agitated patients) for threats and verbal abuse.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Just look at the lame judgements given and the freedom of drugs and mobiles in prison and you can see why it is no deterrence.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So the last Zero Tolerance did not work, why should the new?

    Agression does not have to be physical, and the complaints system is entirely stacked against Doctors in favour of the malicious and vexatious, but only physical violence is mentioned.

    Meanwhile, the same Managers who preside over the Zero Tolerance farce are the same people responsible for ensuring violent patients get care. No conflict there, oh no, not at all.

    More political bllx.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Recently a patient made threats against me. The nhse/ pcs attempts to hamper our emergency delisting of the patient were by far the most distressing part of this experience.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree this is all just a load of empty rhetoric so I thought you might as well all have a laugh at 2 examples which happened to me over the years: 1. One of my drug users stabbed another with a screwdriver he happened to be carrying with him during an argument in the waiting room of our local CDT clinic. They barred him from their premises. He ended up in court and the judge issued a court order that he had to see his GP for treatment. We referred him to our local violent patient scheme but were told that "as the violent act was not committed on your premises, we cannot take a referral from you". I ended up with him in my consulting room waving his court order and demanding medication, with my staff hovering outside and a finger on the panic button. 2. Patient allocated to my list with a history of violent conduct (no info from previous GP as Crapita had lost the notes) threatened me on a home visit. Rang NHSE for advice on how to get him removed as I was apprehensive about seeing him agsain. Response to my PM was "can't the GP take a nurse along next time?"
    I ask you...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Do We have a zero tolerance on verbal abuse also? Or is this tolerated?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say