This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pulse june2020 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

GPs go forth

GPs not prepared to 'shore up' urgent care, warns Buckman in last speech to LMCs conference

Dr Laurence Buckman has warned that GPs are not prepared to ‘shore up’ urgent and out-of-hours care and cannot become ‘providers of last resort’, in his last address at the LMCs conference as GPC chair.

He received a standing ovation after accusing Jeremy Hunt of ‘spouting rubbish’ in continuing to blame GPs for the pressures on A&E services, after a series of speeches from the health secretary claiming that the 2004 GP contract has had a ‘devastating impact’ on out-of-hours care. Mr Hunt is due to make a major speech on general practice later this afternoon.

Dr Buckman also told GPs that they may have to work in bigger partnerships or ‘federate through some kind of franchise system’ to cope with the economic pressures faced by the profession.

Speaking at the 2013 LMCs conference in central London, Dr Buckman said: ‘Despite all the evidence, Hunt continues to tweet that it is all the fault of the GP contract. This is because he does not want to bother with the facts when he can have a bash at those of us who, on his own admission, are over-worked and strained beyond endurance.’

‘Hunt has continued to spout this rubbish when on Tuesday he told MPs that our contract had had “devastating impact” and that pressures on A&E services were “direct consequences of the disastrous changes”.’

Unless the Government changed its approach, patient safety would be endangered, he added. ‘If we don’t work together constructively to find a way forward, we’re quickly going to have doctors all over the country so desperately worried about their patients and their colleagues that they will follow the example of a group comprising almost all of the medical leads of emergency departments in the West Midlands who last week wrote an open letter to trust chief executives and CCGs to say they could no longer guarantee safety in their units.’  

‘GPs are not prepared to shore up a system that has been rendered unsafe by unwise political meddling. We are happy to work closely with others, including CCGs where there is full GP input, to improve out-of-hours services.’

Click here to read the speech in full

Dr Buckman warned that GPs were already overloaded with work. He said: ‘The fact is GPs are undertaking more consultations per patient and we are diagnosing and treating more conditions that ever before. The fact is that GPs cannot become the providers of last resort for urgent out-of-hours services.’

But he also told delegates that economic pressures meant that GPs would have to work differently in future.

‘We may have to work in bigger partnerships, or federate through some kind of franchise system as some GPs have done,’ he said. ‘I think that economic pressure is going to make this happen and we would be wiser to lead the wave rather than follow it. Why do some patients want continuity with few GPs while others want a quick service whenever they access it? Is it just about the age of the patient and their co-morbidities?’ 

‘GPC and LMCs have to get on and find out. Our debates this week will get this going but we all need to recognise that the aspirations of younger GPs are different. They do not want to work in the same way as many of us have always done and we have to consider their futures too.’

Dr Buckman also warned that some inspectors and appraisers would ‘see their role as enforcers’ and his mention of the new chief inspector of primary care received loud boos.

He said: ‘On the regulatory front, just when we thought we could not be more closely observed, we can now expect a new chief inspector of primary care. GPs are committed to providing high quality care to their patients and will work with the new regulatory framework to ensure that patients continue to have confidence in their local practice. But, as ever, the system needs to be practical, proportionate and supportive.’

‘With revalidation and the CQC registration of general practice – both introduced in the past year – we have liaised closely with the organisations involved to make it work, for patients and doctors.  But despite all this effort, there are some appraisers and inspectors who see their role as enforcers, out to rid the service of GPs who do not fit with their view of what GPs should be. How such people get into positions of power over others I do not know.’ 

Dr Buckman, who steps down from his role as GPC chair after six years in July, also paid tribute to BMA colleagues and members.

‘My future is to go back to my practice and try to stop the Government from bankrupting it,’ he said.

‘Some of you will breathe a sigh of relief, though not as much as my wife. I have been privileged to be elected to the task, and to have received the support of most of the 46,000 GPs.’

Readers' comments (21)

  • Its all talk.When it comes to the nitty gritty our beloved leaders have no backbone to stand up to the government.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I think the Government has to realise that if they carry on denigrating GPs and not alleviating their workload, there will be no surgeries for people to visit.

    The exodus of GPs is beginning. GPs in the late 40s are considering the unthinkable, namely emigration. That is how intolerable general practice has become.

    The over 55s are looked at enviously as they can walk at any time.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hunt blames the 2004 contract change for increased attendances at A&E. Kins Fund says attendance at Major A&E units up 0.18% per annum over last 10 years. Counting changed to include MIUs and WICs in 2004.
    Typical politician - never let the facts get in the way of agood story.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • James Kirkup is Deputy Political Editor for the Daily Telegraph-read his "critique" of BMA vs Gov:

    "On the face of it, Mr Hunt’s suggestion – that people who are paid a lot of money to do a job should try to do their job better – should be entirely uncontroversial, even banal"

    Mr Kirkup is paid alot of money, so why can't he do a better job at Journalism than this sad, superficial and tabloid-style rubbish?? Any answers Mr Kirkup?
    How much are you paid? Forgotten have you??

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • In response to Anoymous at 11.09 - Laurence has worked tirelessly over the years on your behalf - I expect in stead of moaning you are going to step in do better - Well good luck to you, because you will need it - lets see if you can do any better

    God bless Dr Buckman - enjoy the time you spend with your patients at least they are grateful, Clearly the GP's you have fought tirelessly to protect
    do not

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dr Martin Scurr-GP and writer for The Daily Mail has recently again been attacking GPs regarding out-of-hours..........

    "Nowadays, all that has changed because GPs have given up on their moral duty to provide out-of-hours care.

    Who is this medical "moral guardian and mentor??" who writes for THE DAILY MAIL?????

    Dr MARTIN SCURR IS A MULTI-MILLIONAIRE PRIVATE GP who runs the Private Notting Hill based GP practice serving bankers and celebrities and bought a property in Ladbroke Grove (number 121) in 2007 for £2.45 million-information freely available from searching the web.
    Yet this man who can't be bothered to serve the man-in-the street who can't afford his £50 minimum telephone charge at his practice for out-of-hours provided by an on-call service rather than Dr Scurr has the disgusting cheek to attack NHS GPs. I demand that this man is referred to the GMC-he has repeatedly breeched Duties of a Doctor in abusing his colleagues and distorting facts.

    Read more:
    Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Yes, I agree-let The Daily Mail reveal an exclusive news story about Dr Scurr's wealth !!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Come on Daily Mail..........tell the punters who Dr Scurr really is and his background....he ain't no regular GP now is he????????

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Come on Daily Mail !!!! Gone silent?? Lost your voice all of a sudden???

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Yes, I think we should be lectured on morals by a multi-millionaire private GP !!! Does Dr Scurr run educational days or lecture circuits on morals that I could attend???????

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say