This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

Ninth GP surgery set to close in single town

A ninth GP surgery is to close in Brighton and Hove in less than four years as a result of a partner retirement.

The patient list from Hove Park Villas Surgery will be taken over by another Hove practice, the Trinity Medical Centre, which was created from a merger last year.

A remaining GP partner and a salaried GP from Hove Park Villas Surgery will join Trinity Medical Centre at the end of September.

NHS Brighton and Hove CCG explained that the GPs from Hove Park Villas Surgery had reached out to the nearby practice due to ongoing issues with replacing retiring GPs in Brighton and elsewhere.

The CCG said patients did not have to worry about re-registering with a new GP, as they would automatically move to the new practice.

But the closure of the Hove Park Villas Surgery is another indication of the continuing recruitment challenge and the growing trend for consolidation.

More than 33,000 patients have been affected by the closures and changes which have added to the pressure on the remaining 35 practices in Brighton and Hove. 

Average QOF performance has dipped and the average list size has risen from about 6,900 to 8,700 over the past few years.

Earlier closures in Brighton and Hove resulted from a mix of retirements, the surrender of a PMS contract and the CQC withdrawing a practice’s registration.

They were:

  • Eaton Place in Kemp Town, Brighton, which closed in February 2015 when a partner retired.
  • Goodwood Court, in Hove, which closed in June 2015 when the CQC intervened. Its Eaton Gardens branch surgery, also in Hove, also closed.
  • The Practice Hangleton Manor, run by the Practice Group, in Hove, which closed in July 2016 when the company surrendered its PMS contract.
  • The Practice North Street, run by the Practice Group, at Boots, in North Street, Brighton, which also closed in July 2016 when the company terminated its contract.
  • The Practice Willow House, run by the Practice Group, in Heath Hill Avenue, Lower Bevendean, which closed in September 2016.
  • The Practice Whitehawk Road, run by the Practice Group, at the Wellsbourne Health Centre, in Whitehawk Road, Brighton, which closed in November 2016.
  • Lewes Road, in Brighton, which closed in January last year when a single-handed partner retired.
  • The Practice Group also pulled out of running a surgery in Morley Street, Brighton, catering for homeless people. The contract was retendered, with community interest company,Arch Health CIC, run by the existing lead GP, winning the bid.
  • The Ridgeway Surgery, in Woodingdean, Brighton, which closed last autumn when a partner retired.

The news comes as a Pulse analysis last year revealed that general practice was on the brink of collapse in several towns, including Brighton.

And, last week, the BMA renewed its calls for increased funding as practices in Plymouth are 'on the edge of viability’.

NHS Brighton and Hove CCG has been looking at ways to strengthen general practice in the south coast city and is currently formulating a strategy for primary care.

An NHS Brighton and Hove CCG spokesperson told Pulse that 'every effort was made by the CCG to support the Hove Park Villas Surgery to continue to provide services' but that 'general practice services across the city are facing the same pressures that are being reported from around England'.

But they said that following the merger, patients would 'get enhanced GP services, with extended opening times and broader services from more suitable premises with better accessibility and public transport links'.

The CCG further said it is putting 'measures in place' to 'support' GP practices locally, including educational programmes to 'help them run their surgeries more effectively and efficiently to free up doctors to provide more care for patients'.

'A key area of our plans to improve health and social care across the city is to make sure general practice is more sustainable, more resilient and works efficiently and effectively for many years ahead.

'This will include integrating some services, with other clinical specialists like pharmacists better supporting GPs, and helping GPs work more collaboratively together,' the spokesperson added.


Readers' comments (20)

  • Good, public don't value GP surgery, A&E is open 24 hrs.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Corner shop model be dead init.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The public and the government does not value general practice. They will miss it once it is gone. The 5 year forward view sure is working.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I suspect that those high up would rather not have lots of small organisations to deal with. Of course these people too will get old. Maybe they will not notice the loss of their local branch surgery and a well known doctor to coordinate their care.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hey guys this is new. Don’t worry though we’ve got a union who’ll fight this and I’m sure as soon as the government hear they’ll do anything to stop this.....(tumbleweed).....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This is not government incompetence is it?. Seems a clever and deliberate ploy to cause "consolidation". We are about to close which seems unbelievable.

    First CQC put is in special measures, then we had a hike of 8k to 100k in service charge and now we have an exodus of staff. The locums want £650 a day but are not willing to do vists, paper work on phone calls. I have to work out of hours to have any income as the practice is non profitable.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So Mr Massey, still think we are a council of despair? Or are we just realists.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Does anyone remember when a General Practice partnership was a highly respected and valued position - hard work but sustainable and reasonably remunerated. We only had contact from the then FHSA to sign on as a GP and to receive payment each month
    What on earth has happened to a once proud and fairly autonomous specialty?
    Judging by the numerous cards and good wishes I received from patients when I resigned from practice 13months ago after 34 years patients do value GPs and the service provided.
    The public , however, need to wake up and demand better support for health care
    The government clearly don’t and are running down the service.
    I need not mention CQC and all the other systems and processes eroding general practice
    To run a practice now is taking on a huge liability and constitutes a risk to personal health and well being as the commitment is open ended.
    I really like treating patients and now just do just that half time with none of the meetings of limited value (MOLV ) to coin a phrase, demeaning targets and hoops to claim money taken off the global sum and offered back for work of limited value (WOLV)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There is absolutely no incentive whatsoever for a newly qualified GP to join a small 2/3 partner surgery. Often the income is not great and the risks too many for it to be worthwhile. There is a constant battle not to be left “last one standing” and until this jdentifed and managed these smaller surgeries will continue to close.
    The days where there were multiple applications for partnership has long gone and the cynic in me suggests that this has been done with a long term government plan in mind to decimate small/medium practice. There is no other viable explanation.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Coming soon to a town near you.Things don't look so rosy right along the South Coast. Brighton has its problems, but has a relatively young population, a big teaching hospital, nice place to live, and more than its share of funding. Practice closures in Folkestone, Hastings, Worthing, Portsmouth ...

    Impossible to run a practice on £150/patient gross (globalsum+QOF+LCS+GPFV) without working for free. No wonder they are all going to the wall. All you can eat General Practice buffet 12 months for the cost of 3 tanks of petrol.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say