This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

Four in 10 GPs in favour of charging patients for appointments

Exclusive Four in 10 GPs would welcome being able to charge patients for appointments, a Pulse survey has found. 

The survey of 948 GPs found that 41% are in favour of the NHS charging a fee for appointments, as it could help tackle workload and allow a better use of their time. 

This is a decrease from 2013, when just over half of 440 GPs who were surveyed by Pulse said they were in favour of charging a small fee for routine appointments, compared with 36% who would not.

Under the new five-year contract, negotiated by the BMA and NHS England in January, general practice will receive billions of funding alongside a raft of changes, including financial incentives to join primary care networks and a new state-backed indemnity scheme paid for out of the global sum.

Despite NHS England chief executive Simon Stevens saying the deal 'unarguably represents the biggest boost to primary care in more than 15 years', only 45% of GPs said they would have voted for the contract if it had been put to ballot, with some arguing against the little increase in funding

In Pulse's latest survey, the 387 GPs in favour of introducing a fee for appointments argued this could help drive demand down and tackle the increased pressures.

One GP said: 'Although I have previously opposed this, I now genuinely think that people don't value health care services, either hospital or general practice. We get numerous DNAs, as do the hospital.

'Charging 5p for a carrier bag has reduced the number of unnecessary carrier bags as people think twice. A nominal fee that makes people think about whether an appointment is genuinely needed or if they can access appropriate information in an alternate way might improve unnecessary workload.'

Echoing their comment, one respondent said: 'A small, nominal fee that can be claimed back if on low income. It would make people realise that primary care is a privilege and not unlimited, while not restricting access for those who need it.'

Another GP said: 'I cannot think of any other way of stemming increasing and unreasonable demand other than some form of financial barrier.'

The survey also showed that 41% of respondents are against the practice of charging patients, pointing out it would be 'appalling' and likely to deepen the divide between the rich and poor.

One GP said: 'This would create further health inequalities, drive the inverse care law and create increased, unreasonable expectations. A potential consequence of this would be an increase in investigations, referrals and prescriptions.'

Another GP commented: 'Public support for the NHS is already precarious. We already charge people for their NHS care, through taxes. To charge again would be appalling. The poorest would get sicker.' 

Leading doctors have previously rejected calls for the BMA to consider charging patients for GP appointments in order to fund the NHS, saying co-payments are 'a tax on sickness' and 'clearly not right'.

The issue was also debated at the 2017's LMCs conference in Edinburgh, when GP leaders tasked the BMA GPC with creating a list of the charging options available and their potential positives and negatives despite warnings that passing the motion would send the wrong message. 

Meanwhile, a 2015 YouGov poll revealed that almost a quarter of British people would be willing to pay for GP appointments

 

Readers' comments (29)

  • Nick Mann | Salaried GP10 Oct 2019 5:03pm

    I 100% agree

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Imagine going to a car dealership where everything is free, most will want everything and not bother to even wash the car. Just get a new free one since others are paying.
    The NHS is now treating things to do with making a statement, social problems, parental problems and life style and distracted from treating basic diseases.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • To the 59% who feel the "all you can eat for free" approach is correct and working… Good luck carrying all the work when the rest are finally broken by the current GP land.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Almost every service in the country involves a charge at some level, healthcare is almost unique in the way it tries to hide costs from the user. Charging has benefits over taxation because it ring-fences money for health, something taxation can never do which is why we end up with feast and famine in the NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It is block contract for poor gps. Why would government change any thing and loose votes. These blogs have appeared many times in past and nothing happened. This time it will be no different..
    Paid .
    Limited number pay limited taxes. Those who don't pay taxes have unlimited access. Any thing free at point of delivery is certain to be misused.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Some quite bizarre answers from those supporting charges... implying the NHS is free and comparing Health services to plastic bags.

    Charging doesn't seem to have put off many in the private sector, but of course poor people can't go there.

    I sense some pejorative attitudes towards patients in these comments. Patients are not time-wasters or commodities. Ditch the zombie narratives and start pushing upwards. Patients are the easy target, but not the right target.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I wonder whether the 40% would still vote for charging patients if they were told that the following would exempt from paying. Or, would they have insisted that no one is exempt.
    Income support
    Income-based Jobseeker’s Allowance
    Income related Employment and Support Allowance
    Pension credits
    War Pension Scheme or in Armed Forces
    Pregnant women and those who have had a baby in last 12 months
    Housing benefits
    Universal Credit
    Disability living allowance
    Attendance allowance
    Carer’s allowance
    Cold weather payment
    Winter fuel payment
    Bus pass
    Tax credits
    Free NHS prescriptions
    https://www.caba.org.uk/help-and-guides/information/understanding-benefits-uk-basics-explained

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I'm sad to say I agree.
    Echoing some of the comments above, those who do not agree charging is a good idea need to come up with an alternative suggestion.
    Sadly, in a capitalist society, people only seem to value things when they have a monetary value attached.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There has to be a charge, but the problem is I dont trust ANY politician, born or not unborn to govern this.

    Even a five pound charge will dissuade a lot of pointless GP appointments typically sought by the worried well.

    A lot of people will say they cant afford any fee, but will soon turn up asking for a GP letter detailing the reasons why they have to take their pregabalin on their next foreign holiday.

    I do agree that any fees charged must be similarly enforced at AE.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say