This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

BMA to launch legal challenge to secure death-in-service benefits for GP locums

Exclusive The BMA is in the process of drawing up a legal challenge against NHS Business Services Authority over death-in-service benefits for locum GPs.

GP leaders have said the current system is ‘not acceptable’ as it means locums would have to ‘die at work, at your desk’ in order for their loved ones to access their NHS pension benefits.

Meanwhile, partners and salaried GPs are covered on a continuous basis, with their families able to access their NHS pension regardless of when they die.

This comes after locum GP who died was considered not to have ‘died in service’ because she had not been scheduled to work on the day of her death.

The BMA confirmed to Pulse that it has submitted a test case to the Pensions Ombudsman who is in the process of reviewing it ahead of launching a formal legal challenge against NHS Business Services Authority.

Dr Zoe Norris, chair of the BMA’s sessional subcommittee, said that the BMA had put test cases directly to the NHS Business Services Authority but the GP locums had been told they were ineligible for death-in-service benefits.

She said: ‘So we’ve gone to the ombudsman and we’re awaiting the outcome of the ombudsman’s review and if that doesn’t go in our favour then that will be a legal challenge.’

Dr Norris told Pulse that the BMA is pursuing a legal challenge for clarity regarding the circumstances under which a locum’s family can claim death-in-service benefits. 

She said: ‘It’s unacceptable that locums don’t know if they were to be in the horrible situation of dying at some point, whether or not their loved ones are going to have access to their pension benefits.’

She added that the current situation is such that if a locum was booked to work on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday but died on Tuesday, they ‘wouldn’t get death-in-service’.

She said: ‘So pretty much, unless you die at work at your desk, then the current situation seems to be that you don’t get it.

‘However, there’s a real lack of clarity… and that’s not acceptable.’

Dr Norris said that if NHS BSA give ‘a definitive no’ that locums are not entitled to death-in-service benefits outside of working hours, ‘then we need to be advised about what protection they can take out for that’.

She added that the BMA would like for locums to be granted death-in-service benefits ‘if they’ve got clear evidence that they are currently providing NHS services over the previous six or 12 months’.

She said: ‘It should be continuous. We are paying into the NHS pension, so we shouldn’t have different benefits for locums compared to other GPs.’

The Department of Health and Social Care told Pulse that GP locums benefit from the flexible lifestyle of temporary work and in choosing a locum career should consider the terms of the NHS pension scheme and make sure they make arrangements to cover the unfortunate event of dying prematurely when out of work. 

Related images

  • Money - stethoscope - private - charging - RF
  • GP and patient male

Readers' comments (6)

  • At last some good work from BMA. Should I join BMA?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • another reason to retire early then locum ad hoc. only 4 years, 2 months and 11 days till early retirement day (TERD for short for government usage) so only 1531 TERDs to go !!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Under any other government regime this would seem easily solvable in our favour.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • AlanAlmond

    A great idea but unfortunately it comes from the BMA...I guess we can all assume it’ll get nowhere then. What took our ‘union’ (sic) so long? This has been an issue for years. Waiting for the wrong moment to make their move no doubt. I’m not a member. God helps those who help them selves. Expect nothing from a process initiated by the BMA. An organisation programmed to show weakness where there should be strength.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • End of the line?

    If you have active medicolegal cover to allow NHS work then that should be enough to state you are in service ??
    WHY DOENT NHS England just state they prefer to steal your pension contributions.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Rein in your horses before you think of joining the BMA, its always been a BADLY MANAGED ASSOSIATION (BMA).

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say