This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

#GPnews: Daily Mail 'names and shames' GP practices that close for training

14:05 A public consultation meeting to discuss the NHS "sustainability and transformation plan" (STP) for Cornwall earlier this week didn't go quite to plan, writes Cornwall Reports.

According to the write-up, the meeting in Penzance 'ended in chaos as an angry crowd refused to be “organised” into small workshop groups and instead spent 30 minutes telling NHS chiefs that they should focus on securing more investment for Cornwall’s health service'.

It says Garth Davies, of the Royal Cornwall Hospital Trust, 'got as far as telling the crowd that lifestyle issues lay behind 75% of premature deaths before, one after another, people stood up and demanded information which the health chiefs said they simply did not have'.

The workshop group-free meeting ended up closing early, and a comment sheet inviting 'questions, comments and feedback' ended up only with the block capital message 'ABSOLUTE SHAMBLES', according to a picture from the event.

Whilst not exactly the Brixton riots, Cornwall Reports says the Penzance lot were 'more rowdy' in nature than their counterparts in Bude, 'where a smaller – and significantly more elderly – crowd had divided obediently into small workshops to consider the relative merits of differing aspects of the health and social care system' on the previous evening.

11:50 South London GP and former RCGP chair Professor Clare Gerada was on BBC Newsnight yesterday calling for more money for general practice, and the NHS in general.

She said: 'It's sometimes too easy to say "we need more money", but we need more money. We have an incredibly cheap health service. We eke out so much care from our health service.

'We have one of the most efficient health services in the world. And do you know what? The health service is a precious gift to the people of this country. If we lose it, we will all be the worse off for it.'

Further, asked about the British Red Cross statement that there is a 'humanitarian crisis' in the NHS, Professor Gerada said: 'I wouldn't use the term humanitarian crisis but I think it is a human crisis.

'I think it's a human crisis for those elderly people waiting hours on trolleys, and I think it is a human crisis for those children with mental health problems having to travel hundreds of miles to find a hospital bed. 

'And it is certainly a human crisis for my profession, who are trying to deliver and are unable to deliver - and so it is certainly a human crisis.'

09:45 The Daily Mail is continuing its reporting following on from the NAO report into seven-day GP services, with a headline stating 'The doctor WON'T see you now: Mail names and shames some of the thousands of GP surgeries shutting up shop in the afternoon'.

According to the article, 'thousands of GP practices are closing their doors on afternoons, while others take a three-hour lunch break', while some are 'accused of playing system and claiming extra cash by staying open slightly later one evening a week'.

It says this comes as the NAO report published yesterday found GP practice opening hours were partly to blame for the A&E crisis.

The report comes as RCGP chair Professor Helen Stokes-Lampard already released a statement yesterday explaining why GP practices sometimes have to close during the day and that patients are still being cared for.

She said: 'On occasions where practices might have to close for a short time, perhaps for staff training, adequate cover arrangements will always be put in place, and we make sure that, wherever possible, patients are fully informed well in advance.

'It’s also the case that while a practice may be temporarily closed to patients, it does not mean that care isn’t being delivered - GPs may still be using this time to conduct telephone or online consultations for patients, or by making home visits. This is especially the case for practices with fewer GPs who cannot leave other clinical staff without GP cover whilst they go out on home visits, and so the practice has to close temporarily.'

As Pulse reported, the NAO also found that seven-day GP opening cost 50% more than regular hours and may not be cost effective at this point in time.

But despite this, health secretary Jeremy Hunt went on to hail the seven-day access scheme to MPs in the House of Commons yesterday. Read the full story on that here.

Seen something interesting? Email or tweet @pulsetoday with the hashtag #GPnews

Related images

  • Live Blog

Readers' comments (15)

  • Semms as though Hunt has told his press lapdog to take the heat off him again!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Healthy Cynic

    I'm hoping Dr Stokes-Lampard (let's call her HSL) will help to lead us out of this mess.
    We are all (or mostly) polite professionals. We have asked, pleaded, wited patiently etc for the government/GMC/CQC to listen to reason. They won't or don't.
    We will never have the approval of the Daily (hate) Mail, and we don't need it. We do have the respect of most of our punters.
    It's time to take back control as a profession. We decide whether extended hours or 7-day opening are a good idea. We do care planning if we think it is useful. We refer into hospital when appropriate. We reject CQC fees and stupid inspections.
    It's time for the worms to turn.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Council of Despair

    wondered how long it would take for us to get the blame.

    i feel sorrow for my female colleagues who are being singled out by yet another poisonous daily mail article. The size of pension pots are also being blamed - the inference being it is the reason why GPs are leaving.

    i think we should be looking at a plan B as it's clear the government will not back down (they 'won' the junior doctors dispute), NHS care is getting to the point that it is no longer safe, whatever happens the plan is to dump more demand and risk on GPs so even if we wait for politicians to come to a decision we will be first in line for workload dump and last in line for support.

    time to go.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I wouldn't wipe my arse with the DM. Apart from being too abrasive, its already loaded with crap.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • In Northern Ireland we had hoped to walk away from the NHS gp service, with our current political hiatus here the world has moved on somewhat, looks like we are getting agent hunt as our doh secretary as mrs O'Neill will not resume her role,

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Council of Despair

    recommend reading resignation of this northern Ireland GP - it's also worth reading the comments.

    NI GPs are probably the last hope to save General Practice. If they do not leave the NHS then it is the end of General Practice as it will not be possible to practice safely and we will gradually run out of GPs either because no one will want to do the job. It will be too risky to even take on locum work. Eventually there will be no primary care - at least if GPs leave the NHS they will retain a primary care service to match the republic.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Infamy, infamy, they've all got it infamy !

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment


    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • AlanAlmond

    I actually enjoy wiping my arse with the daily mail but I agree it's fairly abrasive and I do worry about where it's been. I'm actively planning on setting up a novilty business buying the newspaper up in bulk and turning it into toilet paper. I guenuinly believe there'd be quite a market ...might be my ticket out of general practice ..the irony.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The daily lie is a cancer on our whole society..the only comfort is they continually tell hateful bigoted ignorant lies about everyone..except their paid for party the corrupt to the core selfservatives..a transparently evil shit stain on the body politic run by an insane tax dodging deluded multimillionaire
    Like our archaic failing parliament the newspapers need truly revolutionary reform and modernisation ..there is an overwhelming stink emanating from London
    The heil should be reported to the press complaints commiss

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say