This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Welsh GPs vote against 'dangerous' call for mass resignations

Welsh LMCs have rejected the call from the recent UK Special LMC Conference to canvass GPs about mass resignation.

In an emergency motion carried at the Welsh LMCs Conference on Saturday, GPs agreed to reject the decision after LMC leaders said it amounted to ‘dangerous brinkmanship’ that could ‘weaken GPC’s hand’. 

GPC Wales leaders also warned delegates that the Special LMC Conference decision – which demanded GPC canvass members about resigning en masse, if the UK Government does not come up with a satisfactory ‘rescue package’ for general practice – would have less sympathy in Wales, where GPs ‘are in a different place’ to their English colleagues.

Putting the emergency motion to the Welsh LMCs Conference, Dr Sarah Morgan from Bro Taf LMC said: ‘I feel very strongly this is a very, very, very dangerous move which can only devalue GPC’s strength in negotiations.’

Dr Morgan said that ‘brinkmanship is a very dangerous negotiating policy, which only works if the other party does not know the strength of your hand’ and warned that GPs in her LMC were unlikely to sign undated resignation letters if called to.

She also said the call for mass resignation was ‘playground politics’ that ‘devalues our credibility’.

Speaking against the emergency motion, Dr Bhupendra Patel, also from Bro Taf, called for solidarity with GP colleagues in England – reminding delegates that GPs in Wales also voted to threaten mass resignation in 2001 over the same issues of workload and recruitment.

He said: ‘We much show unity to GPC UK and really show our strength, that we are willing resign to establish the depth of the problem we have.’

However, GPC Wales deputy chair Dr David Bailey said that, while ‘we recognise absolutely the strains and stresses that led to the Special LMC Conference’, the GPC is ‘in a different place in Wales, we are not negotiating on the same contract and we are not negotiating with the same people’.

Speaking afterwards, GPC Wales chair Dr Charlotte Jones told Pulse: ‘Whilst we want to show solidarity with our UK colleagues, understanding the problems they are facing in England, actually in Wales it is a very different environment – we have a collaborative relationship with the Welsh Government, they listen to our concerns and they understand, and wants to address, the issues.’

She added: ‘There is no threat from the Welsh Government to impose any change on us… and it would be wrong to use something like this as a lever at the moment – it would be very damaging to the relationship.’

Emergency motion carried at Welsh LMC Conference 2016 – in full:

GPC UK – That Conference calls upon Welsh GPC to reject the motion passed at the Special UK LMC Conference which reads: ‘GPC should canvass GPs on their willingness to submit undated resignations.’

Readers' comments (16)

  • LMC leaders said it amounted to ‘dangerous brinkmanship’ that could ‘weaken GPC’s hand’

    The GPC are holding a busted flush. Don't see how they could be any weaker! Hunt has 5 Aces.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So all med students you now know that the welsh gp leaders will support you fully if you choose a career there!!!!
    Don't hold out more hope for Scotland or Northern Ireland as spending on NHS continues to fall.
    If I had my time again in Medicine, I would be Australian by now!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Scotland is awaiting details of a new contract to commence April 2017 which will change dramatically how GPs work. As a result i think the UK special LMC was mostly about mass resignations in England.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • LMCs are filled with slush that needs to be weeded out at the next elections by hard working GPs. Welsh or English, they are there to strengthen GPCs resolve to work with the government to destabilize general practice. That's why when you get that sort of unacceptable uplift, GPC hails it as a great success and an uplift in real terms.
    Utter nuisance.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • They've loads of GPs in Cardigan Bay!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • A straightforward 50% cut per item pay in 10 years in GP land. A 4% reduction in share from 11.5 to 7.5 % of NHS funding [ approx.] in 10 years.
    Fine, Wales is different. Great.
    So, don't ever complain of being short of GPs, if someday you do not have them.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hence the Welsh minister's 'what crisis' comment.

    Fine, best of luck to you. England will resign.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 11.5 to 7.5 % of NHS funding is in fact a 35% reduction

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Anonymous | GP Partner29 Feb 2016 9:51am 'Hunt has 5 Aces.'
    -7 at weekends!
    Anonymous | GP Partner29 Feb 2016 10:50am
    'LMCs are filled with slush'
    You volunteering to join a LMC then?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The health minister has already started trawling for English G~Ps.dont do it!!....Wales is a small region were everybody knows each other and those in the club protect the status quo.hence many who have crossed the border previously have run back across the bridge pretty quickly

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say