This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Patients risk becoming 'bereft of a GP service' in some areas, GPC warns

The chair of the GPC has warned that patients are at risk of becoming ‘bereft of a GP service’ in some areas – prompting the Department of Health to accuse GPs of ‘scaremongering’.

Addressing the BMA’s annual representative meeting later today, Dr Nagpaul will say that general practice is ‘imploding’, and that continuous defunding of the service has caused a ‘tragic’ and ‘quadruple whammy’ of a crisis in workload, workforce, premises and morale.

He will say that general practice is seeing 40 million more patients annually than five years ago, the greatest rise in any sector of the NHS, that its share of the NHS budget has dwindled from more than 10% to less than 8%, and there was a 15% reduction in GP training applications last year.

But the DH has said it is ‘scaremongering’ to claim general practice is imploding.

Dr Nagpaul will tell delegates today: ‘These intolerable pressures have butchered the joy and ability of GPs to care for their patients, leading younger doctors to shun general practice in favour of a career in hospital, with a 15% reduction in GP training applications last year, and 451 places unfilled. Ministers ignore this workforce crisis at their peril, which seriously risks leaving patients bereft of a GP service in some areas.

‘And whilst the government has announced £650m to ease winter NHS pressures, can you blame GPs for feeling aggrieved that the crisis affecting 90% of patient contacts in the NHS which is in general practice is given zilch, showing a callous disregard for the plight of a profession on its knees.’

The solution, he will say, is to ensure GP services are funded by just over £70 per patient, which he describes as a ‘bargain’ compared to hospital services.

He will say: ‘Therefore, amidst all the headline-grabbing pressures in the NHS, I urge ministers to open their eyes and wake up to the fact that general practice is not just in crisis, it’s imploding. And if the building blocks of the NHS crumble, the NHS collapses too. Not alarmist, not scaremongering. Just fact.

‘I call upon government to finally stop denigrating GPs as the problem, and to see us as the solution. That in an NHS paralysed with cash constraints, it’s logical to invest in the unarguable cost-effectiveness of general practice. GPs are a bargain at the price – just over £70 per patient per year pays for unlimited appointments, home visits, telephone advice, and so forth – a fraction of the tariff cost of a single outpatient appointment.’

But a DH spokesperson said: ‘It is scaremongering to say that GP services are “imploding”. The number of GPs has gone up by 1,000 since 2010 and we’ve taken tough decisions to protect the NHS budget so we can strengthen family doctoring, reform out-of-hospital care and improve GP access for 7.5 million people.

‘GPs agreed to be at the heart of our radical plans for more personalised community care in return for cutting their targets by more than a third to free up more time with patients. GP premises must be fit to help deliver a single, seamless service for the elderly and most vulnerable.’

Readers' comments (25)

  • It'll all be OK, the government can recruit doctors from other countries, for a lower wage.....then all perfect again!
    Oh....well......apart from the fact they can't speak adequate English, or have no understanding of the NHS or cost pressures, or are not as highly trained, over-prescribe and over-refer because that is what happens in so many other countries.......
    D'arn it, thought I had the problem licked!!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    A responsible and elected government will always 'try'( at least try) to listen to all opinions.
    To answer back with words like 'scaremongering' only shows that the speaker is 'really scared' because he/she knows in the conscience that the truth has been said.
    This government is well characterised by bullying behaviour and it now backfires: Michael Gogh Vs Theresa May , David Cameron + Andy Coulson, IDS and Atos, Maria Miller stifling the press to report her scandal, on and on.....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Very stirring speech today by Dr Nagpaul- full of the emotion and frustration I feel daily in the firefighting job as a GP.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Un named spokesman should not be an acceptable source in modern day journalism.

    name the source or don't use their quote. It allows for lazy press offices and lazy journalism

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • @2:51 - coming from somebody who puts a post as 'Anonymous' lol:) Put your name to your post, we GPs don't have the courage to stand out. Let's see who thinks what and don't don't worry about persecution or harrassment. We wouldn't be in the state we are if we had the guts to speak our minds and be united as a profession.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    Those with no virtue holding high positions in the hierarchy , spread the evil through the most. You are probably bored with me saying that by now:
    More to that, the evils are actually fighting against each other.
    There is also another Chinese saying :
    In a time of a regime about to fall, all kinds of evil are surfacing themselves........

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "And if the building blocks of the NHS crumble, the NHS collapses too"

    General Practice is, alarmingly, now like a game of Jenga: keep pulling out the bricks, pile more bricks on top. In an effort to get higher and higher, there comes a critical point, and that's getting closer and closer.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • and don't forget to also hold the patient (or 'consumer') responsible. Their want-driven attitude to health, quick fixes, free prescriptions and treatment and lack of self-responsibility has also driven primary care into the ground.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I don't think that anyone outside Primary Care actually understands that there is a clear and present danger of a manpower crisis. Perhaps what is required is for the GPC or other agency to maintain and publish online a log of GP's intended date of retirement. I know that NHSE is trying to establish such a register though I doubt that it would publish the findings.

    I am happy to start the ball rolling - April 2018 when I will be 55 - if I can hold out that long.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • December 2013 at 54

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say