This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Practices can shut early on Christmas Eve as NHS England makes ‘U-turn’

Exclusive GPs and staff will be allowed to leave early on Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve, after NHS England revised its guidance on the long-running saga.

In a letter to practice managers dated 5 November 2015 seen by Pulse, NHS England said that practices could ‘close doors’ early over the holiday period if they ensured that care provided during core hours was ‘appropriate to meet the reasonable needs of patients’.

The ‘minimum’ this would involve would be an answerphone message directing patients to an out-of-hours service that the practice had made an agreement with beforehand.

The move has been welcomed by GP leaders and hailed as a ’U-turn’ on previous guidance on holiday opening hours.

It comes as Pulse has learned that a practice issued with a breach notice for closing early in 2013 has won its legal battle to have the notice overturned.

NHS England’s new stance represents a reversal of its previous policy.

Its head of primary care, Dr David Geddes, wrote to all area teams in 2013 to insist that it was ‘non-negotiable’ that GP practices open for their full core hours on Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve, warning that practices that decided to close within core hours could be served with breach of contract notices.

But the new letter, written by Ginny Hope, head of primary care at NHS England South, said of Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve: ‘As a minimum, you will need to have a system in place so that patients can access GP services, including urgent care, either by ringing the surgery [and either] being able to talk directly to a clinician [or receiving] an answerphone message signposting the patient to an on-call GP for the practice.’

Dr Robert Morley, chair of the GPC’s contracts and regulations subcommittee, said he had been told the revised holiday opening guidance applied to all practices across England.

He said: ’NHS England has had to do a U-turn, that’s the key message. NHS England has been persuaded by the BMA argument and has accepted what the contractual obligations actually are.

‘There is no contractual obligation for practices to remain open as long as they put in arrangements to deal with emergencies.’

Londonwide LMCs director Dr Tony Grewal, who supported the 11 practices taking legal action against breach notices imposed for closing early, said: ‘We have seen the generic guidance on this from NHS England and they seem to have taken a commonsense view.’

The relaxation of the guidance comes weeks after one of the 11 practices in London had its appeal against a breach notice for early closure over the Christmas holidays in 2013 upheld.

Dr Morley told Pulse: ’One of the practices served with a breach notice has been successful. Each practice was served notices under different circumstances so this doesn’t mean that everyone will win but it has set a precedent.’

Dr Grewal confirmed: ‘There has been a successful appeal against breach notices.’




Readers' comments (22)

  • Ha! Still wouldn't trust them though...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ha ha! We stayed open as ordered last year & didn't have a single patient. They were all too busy preparing their Christmas dinners and wrapping presents to feel unwell!
    Can't trust them though. Will probably change their minds again before we get to 24th or find some other way to penalize us!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • We do booked patients then 'turn up if you want to' every year. Everyone home by 1pm. Duty doctor mans the front desk and then switches phone to mobile if needing to go out. I did last year spoke to 3 people and saw 3. Practice needs covered, contract not breached.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I had a huge number of presents still to wrap last Xmas Eve, so rather than doing my usual and just changing the unwrapped ones to birthday presents I set up the consulting room as a wrapping station. It is a near perfect environment for this activity and unlike at home there was no prospect of being disturbed because who wants to see a GP on Xmas Eve?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    Frankly, we have been opening up to 6:30pm on every Christmas Eve last 10 years unless it fell on a weekend . Apart from a few emergencies , it was really very quiet with any routine appointment . (Sounds a bit like the argument of opening surgery on Sunday??)Hence , as long as there is arrangement to cover emergencies , allowing flexibility is the common sense ..,..

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • first if all,what is early?secondly we are so grateful for this gesture by nhs england aren't we?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • what happened to the previous dictator? too busy eating a large bowl of humble pie I guess

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Massive U-turn
    Forced by a legal decision rather than 'seeing the light'

    But still no apology or resignation?

    As it happens we are a large enough surgery that we do need one doctor present until 6.30 - so it has never been an issue. But if I were a practice that was previously hit with a breech of contract notice, I would be pretty angry right now.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Very nice if you can get it. No thought for emergency or out of hours services.
    Do we close every UCC or walk-in-centre early because it's Christmas Eve or under staff EDs to give more staff a day off. No. Should surgeries close early. I think not.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It's the sort of thing that really shouldn't need to be said. It hadn't been said for the first 25 yrs of my career and guess what happened - nothing!!! We're all perfectly good at managing our core business hours.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say