This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

Gold, incentives and meh

QOF has reached the end of its useful life, says NHS chief

QOF has reached the end of its useful life, according to NHS chief executive Simon Stevens, who said that new GP contracts will phase it out.

Speaking at the Best Practice conference in Birmingham today, Mr Stevens said QOF had ‘delivered the gains it is going to produce’ and had now descended into box-ticking.

He suggested that new models will be trialled by GP organisations who are caring for patient populations of 30,000 plus and take on the new voluntary GP contract.

Mr Stevens said NHS England is currently working with a number of GPs 'on what an additional voluntary GP contract option would look like' adding: 'But a lot of people are saying this is a way of stepping out of and beyond QOF.

'My view is that QOF is now nearing the end of its useful life, it has produced those gains it is going to produce, and for the most part it has descended into too much of a box ticking exercise.'

But he stressed he does not envisage general practice going ‘cold turkey’ on QOF.

He said: 'We have to be thoughtful about how we do that, we can’t just go cold turkey on QOF from 1 April, but in the next 18 months we can use people like the members of the NAPC, to get it right.'

A model for the voluntary contract is due this autumn with the first versions set to roll out in April 2017.

Mr Stevens ended with his assessment of the state of general practice, quoting the Charles Dickens novel A Tale of Two Cities.

He said it was 'the worst of times, in the sense that the pressures have never been greater', but also the 'best of times, in that I do genuinely believe we are moving from denial, through the acknowledgement stage, through to the action stage nationally.’

In the same speech, Mr Stevens also announced that 300 practices are due to be handed funding from NHS England's premises and IT fund, and that 30 CCGs will receive funding to offer psychological therapy in GP practices to patients with long-term conditions.

GPC chair Dr Chaand Nagpaul said: 'We agree that QOF has reached the end of its useful lifespan, and it is good that Simon Stevens agrees with the BMA’s GPs committee as we have already called for the end of QOF in our Urgent Prescription for General Practice.

'This bold step, long overdue, will have a positive effect on practices by reducing bureaucracy and box-ticking, and allowing GPs to focus on the complex care needs of their patients.'

But he added that it was 'important that the phased removal and end of QOF should apply equally to all practices, regardless of their contractual status, and must not be used as a lever for movement away from the current contract to a voluntary local contract'.

He said: 'We believe that patients’ needs are best served under a national GP contract that provides nationally specified consistent standards of care.'

What is the new voluntary contract?

NHS England has said there will be three levels of sign-up to the 10-15-year contracts, which will allow practices to hold on to their GMS contracts alongside the new contract if they so wish, but will also give the option of becoming fully integrated into a 'multispecialty community provider' - which will provide secondary care services as well.

There will also be a watered down contract for practices working in an alliance to provide certain services.

NHS England has said the fully integrated model will include a 'gain/risk share' for acute activity, meaning that funding for the organisations will depend on reducing acute admissions.

The contract will also include a capitation element based on the size of its patient list, and a performance element to replace QOF - as already announced by then Prime Minister David Cameron - and the secondary care equivalent, CQUIN.

The GPC has warned that there were risks to practices signing a local time-limited contract.

Readers' comments (29)

  • What the Chief is trying to say that this pool of guaranteed income money is also going to be lost like the uplifts that have been lost by reducing Practice weightage numbers and moving funds from Primary care. It's happened with half the QoF money and seniority payments so why not go the whole hog and bury general practice.
    There is no transparency so nobody will find out where the 'saved' money went. Ideally,
    one would expect the government to release figures specifying the exact figures saved and where the money has been allocated but this has not happened.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • the nhs wrecker stevens is well beyond his useful life and his NHSE quango has proved to be a complete disaster with the fragmented chaotic NHS he bears considerable culpability for like brain dead nonsense such as personal health budgets.
    the same man who was a prime mover in the national disaster of the internal market which has wasted countless tens of billions diverted from patient care and wastes currently 5 to 10 billion a year for no proven benefit at all except worsening disjointed fragmentation
    please do patient care good by sacking much of NHSE staff and then RESIGN.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I have researched incentive schemes in general and qof in particular.The useful ness of the QOF ended when consultants moved in offering their services to
    improve the performance and practices started recruiting them to improve the performance.The execution reporting is rife,goldbricking as it is known in the trade is prevalent and worst the practice performance is judged by CQC on basis of QOF achievement which has very little to do with outcomes.It is just the record of processes carried out.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 5.35 you missed out one valuable organisation that you can add to your list.... the Great BMA

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The NAPC has now been rewarded for supporting the H&SC Act, 5YFV and STPs. Irrelevant to NAPC and Stevens that hundreds of practices are closing, that is what they want so that practices have to have 30,000 + patients, ripe for ACO and take over by private sector. Health Insurance anybody?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • i fully agree with simon stevens that QOF had its days-i have never supported QOF-the biggest joke is to pay for keeping a disease register which is the most important bit of LTC management- look at the National Statistics about Diabetes out comes-average 50%-there should not be any lower thresholds-one high threshold of 80% achievement and only then the payment should be done-the common statements that is heard is QOF is volutary well then the payments should be also voluntary

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    The most significant part of Dickens' quote was actually the end of the first paragraph at the opening of the book:
    'in short, the period was so far like the present period, that some of its noisiest authorities insisted on its being received, for good or for evil, in the superlative degree of comparison only.'
    Problem is we are losing middle ground politics and the 'best' and 'worst' are all existing for the sake of their arguments , Simon.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The NHS is half wrecked. Ask any nurse or young doctor.
    These guys will wreck it like the rich gps who run ccgs

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There are some good reasons to phase out QOF. One is that it may be driving over-medicalisation in many cases, another that the level of workload is no longer supportable. we can only afford what is of highest value rather than of highest quality given the level of funding in today's NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say