This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

We can do more to help doctors with depression

Dr Charlotte Alexander 

charlotte pic


I have been thinking a lot lately about depression. More specifically, about doctors and depression.

I find myself drawn to the obituary pages of the BMJ, curious about doctors who have come and gone. There have been a number of young doctors recently who have died, and it provokes a strange, pronounced empathy in me, which I have tried to analyse. There is the sense of waste that always accompanies the death of someone young: some have families of their own and others don’t, perhaps haven’t had time, but they are all somebody’s son or daughter. But it is more than that.

It is the sense of recognition that for all their efforts, and we know their efforts, no-one in our profession could help them. It strikes at the core of that infallibility we somehow adopt unconsciously that helps to distance us from our patients but which is ultimately no defence at all. I find myself trying to understand how a doctor could die themselves of metastatic melanoma at 29.

How could that happen in this day and age to someone on the inside? I fear the answer is: all too easily. I don’t know the individual circumstances of this particular doctor, and of course melanoma may be hidden, but I am beginning to think that being a doctor is in itself a risk factor. The stress, the responsibility, the system.

You are trained to survive, not to make a fuss, to push your physical or psychological doubts away - it would be awkward to consult a GP about something that may be nothing. Or perhaps you can never get time off when you want to, you are covering rota gaps, you are exhausted trying to juggle personal and work life, so you leave it. Until it catches up with you and for some, tragically it is too late. Then there are the obituaries where there is no cause, an absence. An omission which makes you stop. You don’t know, but you suspect. A sense of shame begins to start, and you wonder how it could have come to that. There is a sense of guilt when you acknowledge that yes it could, all too easily. This is the dark stain spreading at the heart of medicine, and we are going to have to use our collective energies to name it and stop it or we will have blood (our own) on our hands.

We do it for patients - what exactly is the reluctance to show the same concern for your colleagues?

Caroline Elton is a psychologist who works with doctors who have ‘failed’, and has had more experience than most into what goes wrong. She details some of the doctors who have ended up in her care at various stages in their careers in her book ‘Also Human’. 

She writes about a young, very talented medical student who was in the top for all her academic exams but who came in the last quartile for her SJT (situational judgement test), so was sent to train miles away from any of her friends and family. As a result, she couldn’t cope with the extra demands of her first year and became very seriously depressed.

Caroline Elton wonders how someone could not have picked up on the disparity between this student's two scores and foreseen that there may have been a problem and offered support at that stage. There are many other sobering cases sketched, some of endemic racism or sexism or other kinds of bullying, but the common thread seems to be that no-one is taking responsibility for the personal welfare of trainees or employees. When people are numbers, it is easy to dehumanise them, and the mentality is there right from the start.

If your own medical school is not going to care, the administration staff in control of your four-month rotations at different hospitals certainly aren’t. If you haven’t been aware of the recent publicity around Joanna Poole’s compilation of 400 ‘petty tortures’ undergone by junior doctors on Twitter, I urge you to read them. The small details of annual leave not being granted for weddings or funerals gathered together in one place become amplified to a resonant scream from the ‘junior’ ranks. They are surely the canaries in the coalmine? The lack of control over your working life, the capped pay, the pressure, the lack of understanding shown by managers - isn’t that what the Whitehall study was all about? Are we really going to sit by and let this happen?

As GPs I think we are uniquely placed to change the culture. Partners are powerful managers of culture and can take care of their employees if they want to, even working in a constrained system. If you don’t have daily meetings for all doctors working that day, make it your number one priority. We were once the pioneers of psychological good health in practising medicine as the first adopters of Balint groups - we should be again. If a doctor goes off with depression, what system are you instituting to support them, to find out whether the job played a role, and to grade their return?

We do it for patients - what exactly is the reluctance to show the same concern for your colleagues? It is perverse and needs to change.

Clare Gerarda has been saying this for a while and doing something about it, but she should not be a lone voice. If this was not enough to make a doctor vulnerable to depression, there is finally the personal cost of caring. There is a process of self-extinction at work in our daily professional lives, it is a one-way conversation. It is a debt that builds up which must be repaid.The ability of any doctor to repay it depends in turn on the care they receive themselves.

Caroline Elton calls it the ‘first law of human dynamics’. The emotional energy required to care cannot be created or destroyed, it can only be transformed from one form to another. The whole profession is in danger of running down the supply - we need to put it back. Who knows where it could lead? It could be the best thing you have ever done. A virtuous circle. So we should start small and start today.

Dr Charlotte Alexander is a GP in Surrey

Rate this article  (4.24 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (5)

  • "As GPs we are uniquely placed..."
    4th from last paragraph
    I claim my five pounds in the Balint Bingo please

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The NHS is built very much like the British Empire was, by exploitation of the workers. I remember the 145 hour weeks and the third of your wage paid for overtime. Terms and conditions are a lot better now, but the intensity and pressure are even worse. What needs to happen is a fundamental change to what the NHS delivers. It never could and cannot be all things to all people at all times. Overt rationing is needed. Instead of pursuing endless life expectancy and "improvements" in medical innovation, a realistic expectation of what a publicly funded health care system can and should deliver needs to be done. And it needs to be done now to prevent a total implosion of the system that affects the people working in it and the patients who are relying on it.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 1948 was a naive and juvenile period of time for the practice of medicine in general. Diagnosis and investigation was limited and so was the public expectation of the NHS. The public were grateful for whatever help they were given. When times were hard simply getting the NHS to work harder was enough to get by.

    Since then medicine has progressed to match this equally progressive level of public expectation in what medicine has to offer the world.

    Unfortunately, I feel this advancement has almost come to a plateau yet public expectation continues to rise (antibiotic resistance, lengthening cancer referral times, back-logged psychiatry outpatient clinics, over-loaded primary care services...)

    Aggressive/overt rationing I feel will do nothing to tackle the root cause. Services are already being pruned and carefully allocated.

    The NHS is a victim of its own success. What it really needs is a time machine. Either to go back to 1948 when what doctors had to offer the world was more limited, or to go forward in time where we eventually find the cure to cancer or obtain enlightenment thereby eradicating social depression.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I fear it is not GPs [ again] who are uniquely placed as they are part of the system and depressed themselves.
    It is the Union, the BMA, that needs to define work safety and hours. It can prevent the sort of Dr Bawa Garba situation.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Good article--until

    "As GPs I think we are uniquely placed to change the culture. Partners are powerful managers of culture and can take care of their employees"

    I'm not a powerful anything and I can't look after myself properly--let alone my employees. The ship is sinking. I have much sympathy and respect for the younger doctors coming through. I'm no longer encouraging Trainees into partnership or salaried positions. The opportunities are there for portfolio careers. Locums sessions, walk in clinics, OOH sessions. Rates of £100-£120 an hour are commonplace.
    That's what I would do in their position. It lacks the satisfaction of being a traditional GP--but they have killed that job off.

    Those wanting to enjoy those traditional aspects are best off looking at Canada, and the antipodes.

    Suicide is a drastic but understandable choice for those that are feeling trapped and miserable. There is very little support available for doctors. Its a tragic waste of talented young lives.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say