This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

That déjà vu feeling

Dr David Hogg

I remember the frustration of reading this article in the BBC News back in 2014, when Scottish GPs were being criticised by Reform Scotland for not embracing online appointment booking and prescriptions.

The Scottish Government was quoted as saying ‘online services are currently available to all GP practices in Scotland’ and that it was 'continuing to work to promote and encourage practices to use these services’. As IT lead for our practice, my jaw dropped somewhat.

At the time this was inaccurate. On Arran we were keen to offer online services to our patients. So much so that we had specifically identified it in our IT strategy, and had held multiple meetings with our eHealth team about how to move this forward. I know that many of our members at the Rural GP Association of Scotland (RGPAS) were similarly enthusiastic.

But the problem was that no one in higher echelons seemed willing or able to allow us to switch the facility on. As a practice we were willing to take responsibility for the service - not least as the same system had been successfully rolled out in practices in England and seamless integration was offered. However, we were told that our local eHealth team had to approve all requests. ‘Regional governance’ and 'IP address security’ were cited as the reasons, which seemed reasonable enough - even if a frustrating hurdle towards better online patient access.

However, this was then superseded by the conclusion that in fact a Scotland-wide decision was required. I recall sitting next to a member of the national eHealth team at a conference later in the year. She sympathised with our frustrations over the delay, but promised that it was being looked at as a matter of urgency.

After two years of deliberating, we and other practices received an update. It was deemed that approval was too difficult for a nationwide decision. It would be up to each individual practice to appraise the IT governance required, and take the responsibility, which had previously been moved higher and higher in the mechanisms of the NHS.

So, back to where we started, but at least we were now able to get on with the process of preparing our system for online services. Earlier this year we enabled prescriptions, and just a few weeks ago we enabled online appointments.

So to read this article in the BBC News yesterday gives me a great sense of déjà vu. Once again, individual GP practices are being criticised for poor rollout of online services.

It’s so disappointing that the finger is being pointed at under-resourced GP practices with limited IT support. Some RGPAS members are even continuing to struggle on with Windows XP despite promises to upgrade. Many of them are actually very keen to innovate these services, but have been held back by centralised decision-making.

Our Government needs to be truthful in its response to articles like this. The article unfortunately omits the fact that GPs have been willing IT innovators from the outset, and blames practices for nationally dictated policy. This is somewhat disappointing.

Dr David Hogg is a GP on the Isle of Arran and Chair of the Rural GP Association of Scotland. He writes in a personal capacity. You can follow him on Twitter @davidrhogg



Related images

  • dr david hogg duo 3x2

Rate this article  (5 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (3)

  • Cobblers

    Truth is the first casualty.

    To expect truth from those in power is your problem as long as the mssses believe what they say.

    Not 1984 but nearly.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Feel you pain David. However I don't know why the BBC are doing giving airtime to to that right wing wank-tank (aka Deform Scotland).
    The same Conservative types who are happy to starve public services of funds are always the first to criticise when they fall short.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    Bureaucracy never goes away and has become even more nefarious under this government. We end up taking the blame when things do not go as it was planned.
    The inaction from those who govern us , at all level, certainly had contributed to this negative cloud right on top of our heads these days . I would label this as the new Idleness , one of William Beveridge's original Five Giant Evils .
    Just finished reading Thomas E. Ricks' latest book ,Churchill and Orwell (highly recommend) . In his conclusion chapter , Afterword, he wrote :
    'If there is anything we can take from them(Churchill and Orwell) , it is the wisdom of employing this two-step process , especially in times of mind-bending crisis : Work deligently to discern the facts of the matter, and then use your principles to respond .'
    He also wrote :
    'Orwell especially never stopped trying to see clearly through all the lies ,obfuscations and distractions. Instead of shaping facts to fit his opinions , he was willing to let facts change his opinions.' The last sentence is the most telling to me .

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say