This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

The next time your heart sinks, remember those heartlifters

Dr Zoe Norris

dr zoe norris duo 1500x1000px

We all know the feeling, when we log on to the computer and glance at our surgery for that day. There’s one standout name that makes us take a deep breath and start counting the hours until home time. So what makes a patient a heartsink?

Sometimes it’s the medical side of things – the presentation, the set of symptoms that we know we hate dealing with. Personally, as soon as the patient says ‘I keep getting dizzy’, I immediately want to lay my head on the desk and stick my fingers in my ears.

I’ve done hours and hours of CPD on this. I read the differential, I nod, and then it flies straight out again. I seem utterly unable to retain the information on how to tell the central from peripheral causes, and random nuggets of knowledge then pop into the brain as the patient talks. Ears, brain, emotion – it could be any of them, plus a million more.

For other GPs, it could be presentations of being tired all the time, or menorrhagia, or foot pain, or eyes. We all have those known unknowns where our brains just don’t seem able to process certain bits of medicine.

We cannot forget the patients whose names put a wry smile on your face

But not all heartsinks are about the medicine; sometimes it’s about the person. It could be the very first time you’ve seen them, but something rubs you up the wrong way. It might be the rolled eyes when you apologise for being late, or the production of the four-page list. The description of a colleague as ‘the one with the foreign name’, or the assumption that you will prescribe the 300mg of pregabalin they’ve been getting from their gran’s supply.

If it isn’t the first time you’ve seen them, sometimes the anatomy of a heartsink is multi-layered and complex. Five years of trying to work through a patient’s health beliefs and symptoms and finding your opinion is sought but always ignored is enough to break the hardiest of clinicians. Or maybe going above and beyond and then being chastised for a minor admin issue. Or the complaint you never saw coming.

And just because we are doctors, that doesn’t make us above pettiness either – a patient’s inability to switch a mobile to silent, the child jumping up and down on your scales while their parent looks on, or those wolf fleeces much beloved by some patients in chillier weather can all bring on irritation.

But we must not forget that, for all the heartsinks, there are the opposites – let’s call them the heartlifters. The patients whose names put a wry smile on your face. The ones the adverts for GP recruitment focus on.

You know they won’t mind if you run late, and that while most of your conversation won’t be about medical things (it’s usually about dogs for me), you will finish that consultation feeling like the best doctor in the world. They remind you why you love (or loved) being a GP, and make you feel like you make a difference by just being you. The fact you don’t know the 15 commonest causes of dizziness doesn’t matter. Heartlifters appreciate you more because you don’t profess to know everything. It makes you human and that’s what they value.

If every surgery had only those patients in, it wouldn’t feel quite so hard.

Dr Zoe Norris is a GP in Hull

Related images

  • dr zoe norris duo 1500x1000px


Rate this article  (4 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (5)

  • Such a good point - we don’t think about the heartlifters enough. My only criticism of this piece would be that it spent 3/4 of its length describing causes of heartsink, which I am sure many GPs will identify with to the point of rising irritation on reading... More of a counterbalance of stories of heartlift would have been balm for the worn GP.

    So, here are some types of patients who cheer me:
    The 7 year old who delights in a sticker for being a good boy and high fives you on the way out.
    The older lady who thanks you and says she came to see you as her “granddaughter said you were lovely, and she was right!”
    The person who doesn’t just not mind your late running, but says you are worth waiting for.
    And those with whom you have genuine top banter.

    I look forward to my heart being lifted at work tomorrow!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • David Banner

    Let’s not forget the greatest heartlifter patients of all - the DNAs. God bless ‘em, every one.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment


    Doctors as patients??
    I like to think i am a heart lift when i attend as i already know what needs to be done
    .... here i wrote out a full consult already
    what do you think?
    bet this actually makes us heart sinks
    hence practices often get us
    in with the reg ???

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • My ultimate heat sinks are those that present every week, with the same long list of symptoms, none of which correlate with any clinical signs, and a full list of normal investigations. Generally the underlying issue is a lack of patient desire to take any responsibility for their condition or symptom, and an expectation that further increases in trama-citalo-gaba-orlistat-epam will fix things.
    But it's hard to tell people: "I've done everything I can for you. What do you think you can do that might make a difference?". Cue blank looks and tumbleweed...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • love it

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say