This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

Only quarter of medical graduates rate general practice as first choice

Only a quarter of medical graduates chose general practice as their first choice of specialty, shows a new analysis that sheds light on one of the reasons for a growing crisis in the GP workforce, experts claim.

In results that a former RCGP chair says show how workforce planning has gone ‘terribly wrong’, only 28% of medical graduates cited general practice as their first choice career, compared with 71% of graduates citing secondary care specialties as their first choice career.

This falls well short of the target of 50% of training places being for GPs by 2015 set by former health secretary Andrew Lansley.

The study - published in the Medical Teacher journal - looked at 9,348 questionnaire responses from people who graduated in 2005, 2008 and 2009 one year after they graduated. They were asked to state their choices of long-term career.

It also showed a marked difference between males and females choosing general practice. Around 24% of men cited general practice as their first choice, which remained constant over the three cohorts, while 36% of women chose general practice in 2009 - which was a decrease from the 40% in 2005.

The researchers concluded: ‘General practice is still substantially under-represented in [newly-qualified doctors’] preferences.’

The latest figures on GP recruitment are not encouraging despite Lansley’s commitment. Pulse revealed last year that there had been a decrease in the number of GP training places in England in 2012, compared with the previous year, and a rise in hospital training places.

Study leader Professor Michael Goldacre, a professor of public health at Oxford University, said there was ‘some cause for concern’ about the figures showing a relative lack of interest in general practice from newly-qualified doctors.

He told Pulse: ‘Clearly we observe that a much smaller percentage express a preference for a career in general practice than the NHS actually needs.

‘We note that the deficit is eventually likely to be made up by the fact that doctors will go where the training places and jobs are. That is a mitigating factor.’

The latest figures from the NHS Information Centre show there are rising numbers of consultants practising in England, compared with GPs. Some 39,088 consultants were practising in England in 2011, compared with 27,218 GPs. This compares roughly even figures between the professions in 2001, with 27,782 consultants and 27,938 GPs.

Professor Mayur Lakhani, a former chair of the RCGP and a GP in Leicestershire, said the figures were ‘astounding’.

‘Workforce planning has gone terribly wrong. The system should have been producing more GPs. Instead it has been producing more consultants. The needs of patients are clear – they need more generalists.

‘Pulse’s investigations shows that practices are at breaking point – there is so much work being transferred into practices, and I feel it as a practicing GP. Like a rubber band, it has been stretched and stretched. Yet the numbers of GPs are the same.

‘At a time when all the policies have been about making the health service more primary care centred. Workforce planning has not really delivered extra capacity in primary care.’

He added that educators should look at ways to ensure a higher percentage of medical graduates want to pursue a career in general practice ‘from the outset’.

Professor Bill Irish, who is director of GP Education at the Severn Deanery and chairs a Government taskforce on GP recruitment and retention, said: ‘One of the problems is that not enough people apply to GP specialty training.

‘There is a regional issue too – the Kent, Surrey and Sussex deanery has filled its training places for the past couple of years. But in areas in the north of England, it is difficult to recruit enough to maintain current levels.

‘As a taskforce group, we want to understand what guides or prevents people becoming GPs.’

Professor Richard Baker of Leicester University’s health sciences department, who has been collecting data on workforce numbers over two decades, said the problem was not about an increase in specialists, which was necessary. However, the flatlining of GP numbers was ‘a pressing problem’.

He added: ‘My concern is it not about complaining about the growth in specialists. The anxiety is that it takes a long time to train a GP. And in order to fill the gap, are we going to look to other ways to deliver primary care other than by GPs? We need to have a very informed debate about how to manage that.’  

Readers' comments (26)

  • Spare the platitudes Clare.
    Unless you have strong masochistic tendencies and aspire to being the government's catamite for the rest of your life my advice would be to stay well clear of General Practice.Consider becoming a MP.Now that IS the best profession in the world.You can take credit on the backs of others' hard work and blame them if things go wrong.Who cares about long term consequences.Just get through one term and you're pensioned for life!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • it was always thus - doctors (and students) always want to demonstrate their new skills and usually this includes putting in tubes, cutting or using hi-tech gizmos. when they mature (not said patronisingly) they realise the real skill is in listening, diagnosing and long term involvement - hence switch to GP or psychiatry . We must make sure that it is always possible to switch careers and not box young people in too early to careers that won't sustain them.

    General practice is the best career that one can ever have

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • To the commenter who wrote: Spare the platitudes Clare.
    Unless you have strong masochistic tendencies and aspire to being the government's catamite for the rest of your life my advice would be to stay well clear of General Practice.Consider becoming a MP.Now that IS the best profession in the world.You can take credit on the backs of others' hard work and blame them if things go wrong.Who cares about long term consequences.Just get through one term and you're pensioned for life!
    ------------------------------------------------------
    are you a GP?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • To the commenter who wrote: Simple medical students are clever enough to know its not worth it
    I would strongly urge even those 26 % not to apply for general practice specially if you are not caucasian
    -------------------------------------------
    What a horrible negative post
    Are you a GP?
    I am not 'caucasian' and i find your comment insulting to me - personally.
    Clare

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am a GP of almost 28 years and about to take VER.

    New graduates-> DO NOT CHOOSE GENERAL PRACTICE AS A CAREER. It is a dying profession on the point of being taken over by private companies employing hoards of doctors to be told what boxes to tick and what to do each day. The appeal in the early 80's was that you were fully in control of what you did. This encouraged innovation and pride in your own surgeries services. That has been destroyed and you now simply tick boxes to earn money taken off from you in the past to meet ever increasing practice expenses.

    Move overseas or do a hospital based job where you can have time to do your own private practice.

    LISTEN TO ME> AVOID GENERAL PRACTICE.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The problem I have with many of our leaders is that they are like the "dim academic sterotype"-full of academic understanding but dangerously naive and vulnerable when it comes to other aspects like workforce planning or representing the profession to the DOH. They seem to think (like some kind of hippy) that yeh man, let things evolve, don't tamper with nature. This is all crap. Look we have a massive looming workforce crisis and any leader who doesn't act now is a negligent and incompetent leader who should do the honourable thing and resign. Professions can't rely on good luck to plan the future or self-congratulatory drivel-it requires business planning.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • -you will be hounded by a malicious press for being overpaid
    -work 15 hour days,have a pay cut and and work increase every year
    -dumped on by everyone and anyone who feels they can get away with it

    ITS NOT WORTH IT.The NHS does not value GPs any more than the butcher values cattle.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I chose this career after sitting in with GP`s 12 years ago while at medical school - I decided at that time I wanted to do it. Unfortunately it is a different job now and I wouldn`t choose it again - shame

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This comment has been removed by the moderator.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • General practice has become a chore reduced to ticking boxes and an ever increasing target chasing exercise.I am not sure what benefit patients derive from these changes.Unfortunately,many of these changes appear to be implemented and policed by many of our colleagues who wallow in their newly found powers and titles whilst forgetting those for whom the nhs was established.I would not suggest medicine,let alone gp, to any A level student.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say