Cookie policy notice

By continuing to use this site you agree to our cookies policy below:
Since 26 May 2011, the law now states that cookies on websites can ony be used with your specific consent. Cookies allow us to ensure that you enjoy the best browsing experience.

This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Dilemma: A patient tells you he plans to travel to Syria

Three experts advise

An adult male patient attends for a routine appointment. He mentions he is planning to travel to Syria on his own for several months. You are concerned about the purpose of the trip. How should you proceed?

Dr Fiona Cornish

 

Dr Fiona Cornish: Be sceptical about the patient’s story

This scenario may ring alarm bells. Find out as much as possible from the patient, for example whether the trip is for a humanitarian aid purpose. Inform him that the Foreign Office advises against all travel to Syria.

Be very cautious about what you believe from the patient’s responses, as someone planning terrorist-related activities will probably try to conceal anything suspicious from their GP.

Since 2015, doctors have had a legal duty under the UK Government’s Prevent strategy to have ‘due regard to the need to prevent people from being drawn into terrorism’.1 As GPs, we are required to help identify and refer to the authorities individuals we deem as being at risk of being drawn into terrorism, including violent and non-violent ‘extremism’.

However, confidentiality and trust are at the heart of our relationship with patients. The GMC has reviewed its guidelines in the light of the Prevent strategy and reminds us that we have

a duty to disclose if the law requires it or it is in the public interest.2 As a general principle, doctors should ask for consent before disclosing information about a patient, but the GMC recognises that this is not always safe or feasible. The Department of Health sets out the steps to take if you are concerned that a patient may be involved in, or is at risk of being drawn into terrorist-related activity.3

If, after discussion with colleagues and further investigation, you are seriously concerned about potential terrorist activity, you should contact the local police or the confidential anti-terrorist hotline.4

Dr Fiona Cornish is a GP in Cambridge

Pipin Singh – online – 330x330

Dr Pipin Singh: Identify risk factors before escalating concerns

Your approach should take account of a number of factors. You may have a large proportion of patients who are refugees, asylum seekers or from minority ethnic backgrounds. In that case, a trip to Syria may be understandable.

However, given the current national concerns over increased radicalisation, you may still wish to enquire why he is travelling.

If the patient does not appear to have obvious social links with Syria, explore the reasons for his visit in more detail.

As with any consultation, your style of questioning, level of empathy and overall relationship with the patient will determine how much information you are able to extract.

Does the reason for visiting sound plausible? Does the patient appear restless or anxious when discussing the trip? What is the initial reason for presenting? Your level of concern may escalate if there is any history of mental health problems. Explore the patient’s current social circumstances – his family life, employment situation and housing situation.

You may also wish to review notes of any family members registered with your practice. Be mindful of risk factors for radicalisation – social isolation, mental health problems, drug and alcohol misuse, unemployment, poverty and poor housing.

If after your assessment you have genuine concerns, you have a duty at least to discuss these with the local police who will then liaise with the multi-agency Channel team,5 which reviews cases to help prevent people being radicalised. If you feel there is an imminent risk of harm to others, you must notify the police immediately. Make sure to document your concerns and any advice given.

Dr Pipin Singh is a GP in Wallsend, Tyne and Wear

Dr Harpreet Sarna

Medicolegal view: Remember your overriding duty to report concerns

Despite a number of high-profile cases of individuals travelling to the Middle East to take part in terrorist-related activities, your patient could have a perfectly innocent reason for his trip.

But if after trying to establish the purpose of his travel you fear this may potentially be linked to terrorist activity, you are required to take further action.

It is important to follow the guidance in the Government’s Prevent strategy for healthcare organisations and professionals.3 This advises that GPs are key partners in helping to prevent vulnerable individuals from being drawn into terrorist activities, while recognising that doctors are not required to take on surveillance or enforcement roles. You do not need to be certain of the purpose of travel, or interrogate the family, in order to act on your concerns.

Foreign travel potentially linked to terrorism falls under Section 38B of the Terrorism Act 2000, which requires any individual to inform the police, as soon as reasonably practicable, if they have information that may be of material assistance in preventing the commission, preparation or instigation of an act of terrorism. Your duty of confidentiality is unlikely to be considered a reasonable excuse not to disclose information. And GMC confidentiality guidance recognises that doctors may be justified in disclosing confidential patient information – even where patients have withheld consent – if it is in the public interest to do so, such as assisting in the prevention, detection or prosecution of serious crime.2 It may not be safe or practicable to seek the patient’s consent in the usual way as there may be, for example, a risk of absconding.

In view of the complex and case-specific nature of such a scenario, it is strongly recommended that you also contact your defence organisation for advice.

Dr Harpreet Sarna is a medicolegal adviser at Medical Protection

References

1 UK Government. Prevent strategy. 2011. tinyurl.com/gov-prevent

2 GMC. Good medical practice. Confidentiality: good practice in handling patient information. 2017 tinyurl.com/2017-GMC

3 Department of Health. Building Partnerships, Staying Safe: guidance for healthcare organisations. tinyurl.com/prevent-guidance-hcps

4 Anti-terrorist hotline, telephone number: 0800 789 321

5 UK Government. Channel Duty Guidance. tinyurl.com/channel-guidance

 

 

Rate this article  (3 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (8)

  • Doctor McDoctor Face

    Now Mr Elbaz what is the real reason you are travelling to Syria?

    "Ive come all over terroristy but dont tell anyone"

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • this is ludicrous.
    fundamentally racial profiling and i dont think its my job to be a border guard or policeman at all.

    you could argue the same about people wanting to go to israel - as a lot of people go there to be part of the IDF forces - but as they are usually white it doesnt matter and that sort of mindless killing is ok.

    this is ridiculous.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Syria is a beautiful country containing many historical monuments of great importance, which are being destroyed at a dreadful rate, as well as being the location of several sites of various religious significance.
    It is unlikely that the adviceto avoid travel to Syria will be lifted soon.
    It is therefore imperative he go now, or all that is to be seen may be missed.
    However, it is not safe for him to take family or friends with him, so he should travel alone.
    I just hope he does have some useful language, and plenty of sunblock, but we could give indicated immunisations.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • err. isn't this what the passport people are for at the airport?

    is it normal for jihadists to make sure that their immunisations are up to date before martyring themselves?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Just make sure he can't get back in...........

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • AlanAlmond

    QB had you not noticed there is a nasty civil war going on in Syria. Thousands of people have been killed there and continue to be killed there. A significant number of those fighting sympathise with an organisation that has inspired the senseless murder of innocent people of all races and religions in this very country within just the last few months. There are hundreds of fighters from the UK in Syria who may return with the desire to kill en mass...in this country...where you live?
    You are a Dr? Your hypothetical patent plans to travel to this country and you think its ‘ludicrous’ to consider wether this is wise. You even go so low as to suggest the very idea is somehow racist.
    I find your post offensive and lacking sense. I would be worried if you were employed in my practice.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Good job im not employed in your practice A Virtual nobody..!

    Again, if people plan to travel to any other country its not my job to suggest anything. Nor is it yours? How would you feel about it if someone was travelling to Israel to be part of the IDF? Im sure you wouldnt have the same reply.

    You have been reading too much of the Daily Mail - so ill leave you to it. Just as in the US, homegrown ills such as lightning probably kill more, but read and believe as much right wing propaganda as you will

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • AlanAlmond

    QB - Anti Semitic and quick to take offence. Interesting combination. I suspect you generally ‘debate’ these matters with folk who agree with your niche world view. Try getting my out more my friend. You might feel more relaxed. Good luck with your practice and take care.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say