Cookie policy notice

By continuing to use this site you agree to our cookies policy below:
Since 26 May 2011, the law now states that cookies on websites can ony be used with your specific consent. Cookies allow us to ensure that you enjoy the best browsing experience.

This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Orthopaedic groups apologise after claiming that ‘GPs not doing their job properly'

The representative groups for orthopaedic surgeons has been forced to apologise after putting out a public statement claiming GPs are to blame for patients undergoing needless keyhole knee surgery.

The British Orthopaedic Association (BOA), in a joint statement with the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK), said patients were being set up for failed arthroscopy because GPs were over-diagnosing patients with non-arthritic complaints and referring them on with the expectation the surgeon would ‘cure’ the problem with the keyhole procedure.

It also claimed GPs were not ‘doing their job properly’ by failing to prescribe exercise to patients before referring them for surgery.

This sparked fury from GPs, including Hampshire GP Dr Michelle Sinclair, who accused the groups of being ‘patronising, arrogant idiots’, while others pointed out that they ‘refer to get an expert opinion, not an operation’ and that the BOA/BASK response amounted to ‘unbelievable peer-bashing’.

RCGP chair Professor Maureen Baker tweeted that she was ‘outraged and saddened’ by the statement.

However, the groups quickly moved to apologise to GPs, saying it was not their intention to ‘criticise or offend’.

The original statement by the orthopaedic groups was in response to a BMJ paper - widely reported in the lay press - in which experts said arthroscopy should be phased out.

They argued it offers only very limited reductions in pain while putting patients at risk of life-threatening complications such as deep-vein thrombosis.

The team said that one reason so many patients are still undergoing the procedure - some 150,000 in the UK every year - is because surgeons were biased in their belief it worked.

BOA/BASK hit back with a statement to their members and patients asserting orthopaedic surgeons only offered arthroscopy when it was appropriate and that many patients with arthritis were wrongly being referred by GPs for the procedure.

The statement began: ‘Many GPs have direct access to MRI scanning, believing that performance of this investigation replaces the traditional medical skills of history taking and physical examination of the patient.’

It continued: ‘If MRI scanning is performed too early in the investigative pathway then over diagnosis of meniscus lesions predominates. Very often the arthritic knee has an associated and often irrelevant meniscus tear. The MRI scan result then triggers referral to an orthopaedic surgeon with the expectation by the patient that the knee problem can be “cured” by a knee arthroscopy.’

BOA/BASK also said that - contrary to the paper’s assertion that patients should be advised to take exercise instead of going ahead with surgery - GPs should already have tried this before referring a patient.

The statement read: ‘It is stated that such patients should be treated with exercise, but if GPs are doing their job properly, exercise should already have been prescribed in primary care.’

However, following Professor Baker’s intervention on Twitter, the groups issued an apology.

They said: ‘Following the response to the BOA/BASK statement regarding knee arthroscopy dated 19 June we would like to clarify that our intention was not to criticise or offend GPs. The aim was to highlight the gaps in the MSK general knowledge base and we apologise to our colleagues.’

Readers' comments (56)

  • Stop press - Orthopaedic surgeon sprains knee whilst kicking a GP .

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "our intention was not to criticise or offend GPs. The aim was to highlight the gaps in the MSK general knowledge base"

    Wow, talk about a back handed apology.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • In most areas it is impossible to refer patients to Orthopaedic Surgeons without patients first undergoing a full exercise program under physiotherapists.

    Besides why are Orthopaedic Surgeons doing arthroscopies if patients have not had exercise programmes?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Does this mean orthopaedic surgeons will stop accepting patient's money for arthroscopies?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So orthopds still did the unecessary operations then. Who's not doing their job properly? Is this just another manifestation of patients education that everything can be fixed?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This is very insulting to GPs. This is medical school criticism 'Many GPs have direct access to MRI scanning, believing that performance of this investigation replaces the traditional medical skills of history taking and physical examination of the patient.’
    I would have expected a more analytical and professional response from this group instead this tripe. Besides, this is the type of fallacy of hasty generalization that I would expect from ignorant people who have not idea what medicine is about. Do GPs command them to do arthroscopy? Direct referral to an orthopaedic surgeon in a lot of areas is near impossible without patients going through the physiotherapists and the advanced practitioners.
    Also, I do not see any apology here. Pulse, your headline is wrong.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Are they saying they are just plebs
    who are refered knees to give an expert opinion on and instead of giving this carry out a pointless procedure without questioning why the patient was a referal in the first place.The power of the GP we make the decision they do our bidding,nothing to do with the payment by results payment that goes to the hospital,or generating needless demand.Do they even bother to read our letters.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Appalling arrogant behaviour to pass the blame to GPs when Orthopaedic Surgeons are to blame for performing arthroscopies, not the referrer

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Never heard of them but it's hardly an apology. This sounds like blinkered buck-passing. I would hope that specialists would know what they were doing in their own field and not perform unnecessary procedures having second guessed the GP intention. I don't refer for arthroscopies - I refer for advice.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "Many GPs have direct access to MRI scanning, believing that performance of this investigation replaces the traditional medical skills of history taking and physical examination of the patient."

    Any evidence for this? Surely usually the result of history and examination?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say