This site is intended for health professionals only
Thursday 23 February 2012
Facebook Twiter Linkedin

Cameron accuses GPs of giving preferential access to ‘dinner party’ cliques

By Gareth Iacobucci | 11 Jul 2011

Prime Minister David Cameron has launched a scathing attack on the access to primary care offered to patients, claiming GPs are giving preferential access to 'people with money' who they meet at dinner parties.

The Prime Minister made the claim in a speech yesterday in which he vowed to end the ‘incredibly unfair' system of provision caused by the state's ‘monopoly' of public services, which he argued could be remedied by creating more opportunities for private and voluntary providers. 

Mr Cameron was speaking at the launch of the Government's radical white paper Open Public Services, which outlines proposals to give individuals and local communities more control and choice over the services they receive by breaking up the current system.

In proposals for the NHS, the white paper expands upon Government plans unveiled last week to push ahead with the release of a raft of comparative data on GP performance, including prescribing rates and clinical outcomes, as part of an ‘information revolution'.

It pledges to proceed with plans to abolish GP practice boundaries, giving patients ‘a clear ability to choose to register with a GP practice not restricted by where they live', and vows to make it easier for patients to register at a practice or book an appointment to see their GP online.

Launching the changes, Mr Cameron said: ‘It astonishes me that it's those who call themselves progressive, who say they're on the side of the poorest, who are the most anti-opening up public services. It's the current system that is incredibly unfair.'

‘People with money can get friendly with their local GP at a dinner party, maybe see them out of hours if there's an emergency. In this world of restricted choice and freedom it's the poorest who lose out.'

The whiter paper identifies five key areas for driving change - increasing choice wherever possible, decentralising power to ‘the lowest appropriate level', opening up public services to a greater range of providers, ensuring ‘fair access and fair funding for all', and making services accountable to users and taxpayers.

The Prime Minister added: ‘I know what our public services can do and how they are the backbone of this country. But I know too that the way they have been run for decades – old-fashioned, top-down, take-what-you're-given – is just not working for a lot of people.'

‘Open public services are going to mean you in control. No more take what you're given. No more like-it-or-lump-it. Right across public services we're putting you in charge like never before.'

READERS' COMMENTS

Vinci Ho, GP Partner,
11 Jul 2011
Interesting time to make this speech , Anakin !
So it is green light to go ahead after the infamous PAUSE. ,especially Lib Dem has no complaint with the revised health bill.(Remember the Viceroies in Star Wars).
Hence this is the time to exert his authority and fire ten thousand arrows towards GPs.Absolute scaremonger.....
By the way ,President Skywalker ,when was the last time you had dinner with your friends in News of the World (RIP today) ?
There is a Chinese saying ,'The one who comes around and talks about rumours and controversies is himself a man of controversy .'
The war of the galaxy has just begun........
Average (0Votes)
Top
Spencer Nicholson, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
a wise man once said to me that money doesn't make you happy, it just gives you the ability to make choices, to choose do i have lobster or filet mignon. Apparently the govt has no money ergo you cant have a choice, and considering you already have the cheapest 1st world health system and are even cutting back on that, i think the choice argument is parrot ie dead. and when i was a gp in england i kept work and social separate. friends could ask my opinion but i firmly directed them to their own gp for any treatment. think Cammers has lost the plot unless he is talking about the golf playing surrey mob of gp's who look after news international execs
Average (0Votes)
Top
Gavin Jamie, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
Shome mistake shurely.
I have not been to a dinner party in years. It is Mr Cameron himself that you can meet for cash a dinner party. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/7966879/David-Cameron-dragged-into-cash-for-access-controversy.html
Average (0Votes)
Top
Roger Neal, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
Utter bollocks, pots, kettles and black are words that spring to mind.
Average (0Votes)
Top
Julian Hall, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
Mr Cameron is obvioulsly delusional considering his sense of reality-time to stop sniffing the solvents Mr PM. His public school boy background obviously afforded him such great insight into social dynamics, he thinks he knows more about the average GP's social calender than Dr's do. What a twat! Since when to most GP's attend dinner parties with their patient's in attendance-utter bollocks. He's just slinging mud at GP's to deflect the shit storm facing him in the wake of his relasionship with corrupt press officers and ahead of the BMA's action on pensions. Leave the fairy tail stories for your children Mr Cameron.
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anonymous, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
What a fantasist. I work in an area of towerblocks, many people are on benefits. We get shouted at over issues with the benefits agency ie decisions over work. People shout that they will go to their MP if they don't get an immediate appointment. There are no cravates in sight or bottles of Chateau Lafite for Christmas, no Bentleys in the carpark rather old beer cans and litter. I will give you a clue-I don't work in Kensington or the poshest parts of Surrey Mr Cameron.....OK!!!
Average (0Votes)
Top
Julian Hall, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
And remember, Dr's are one of the most trusted professions by the UK public. Politicians, I believe, rank somewhere in between used-car-salesmen and reporters for "News of the World".
Average (0Votes)
Top
Rupen Kulkarni, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
GPs at dinner parties with their patients ??? And how do GPs gain by giving special treatment to their rich patients??? The service is free for any patient who wans to see their GP. Just like MPs, GPs run an appointment system for different types of problems. What planet is the PM on?? I am told Rabies is curable if treated early. The country must wake up and act quickly !!!
Average (0Votes)
Top
Paul Conroy, Practice Manager,
12 Jul 2011
Load the feedback cannon folks - its shoot-a-hypocrite time.
I suppose he'll now look at the work GPs are doing as gatekeepers to the benefits system, or signing off gun licences and remove these elements so that they can focus on clinical care will he? Will he heck.
If anyone was in doubt we'll be set up to fail - look no further - "my dear GP colleagues, please take a huge hit to your budget against a backdrop of health inflation four times the rpi, and then disolve your certainty of income, deliver better outcomes and greater choice." Oh dear
Average (0Votes)
Top
Hal Maxwell, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
What arrogant nonsense.
I live & work in a rural area, many of my friends are also patients. Landed gentry have estates nearby
BUT they all make appointments and sit in the waiting room
Their friendship or status does not make any difference to access
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anonymous, PCT,
12 Jul 2011
It was some bloke going to dinner parties with a few select friends and family who also happen to be GPs that produced the whole reform mess.
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anonymous, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
Dear Mr PM
Please Wake up and come out of your ivory tower into the real world. It is still not too late.
Dear Mr Cameron
Stop relying on the ill-informed twats that you have surrounded yourself with.
Regards.
Average (0Votes)
Top
Vinci Ho, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
Editor , don't let this stop!
We demand an official apology from the PM
Average (0Votes)
Top
Torquil DuncanBrown, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
I cannot believe this from a man I thought I had some faith in. I would invite him to spend some time with me and see just how his crazy ideas and targets are driving the very thing that he now abhors! If ever there was an inflammatory comment from a man at the top, and at a time when morale is hitting a low and record numbers of GP's are leaving the country! Just how out of touch can he be..... I wonder if this view of his was formed after chatting to a disgruntled colleague - at a dinner party perhaps?!
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anonymous, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
Utter utter tosh and Cameron knows it. The usual political claptrap to get the electorate to think HMG are on their side. Smear, smear and smear again.Some of the political classes will stoop as low as possible in their self interest but coming from the PM? Not surprising mind you in the same week as News of the Screws goes down the pan and certain police officers face questioning about their behaviour. Is the word Integrity still in the English Dictionary?
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anonymous, PCT,
12 Jul 2011
So to date Lansley has insulted the whole of the NHS Management Team and now all GP's. Excellent method of getting the profession to support your NHS Reform's. Reform being privatisation - which is will not create an unfair system - will it!?
Average (0Votes)
Top
Peter Bennett, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
This is a worrying throw away remark in the middle of a planned speech. It feels like we are being judged by seemingly Camerons view that money buys power and influence and we are tarred with this brush. Just because he has perhaps had some ill judged dinner party guests does not mean we all do this. Yet another smear on the profession. It seems he wants to deflect criticsm of his own problems with grace and favour on to us. Not really a good way to influence an already disillusioned profession.
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anonymous, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
What world is this guy living in.Also some of the rather apologetic comments by some of my colleagues beggars belief.No wonder General Practice is in this sorry state
Average (0Votes)
Top
Kamal Sidhu, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
This is an utterly irresonsible statment and only alienates GPs from the establishment.. Bad politics.
Average (0Votes)
Top
Mark Preston, GP Partner,
12 Jul 2011
Unbelievable! He is so out of touch and so insulting. But it says more about him than it does about GPs. Just because 'people with money' can influence him doesn't mean they get access to GPs. Imagine, dinner parties with patients present - it’s never happened to myself or my partners.
Please somebody get Mr Cameron his medication quickly; he needs help.
Average (0Votes)
Top
Showing 1 - 20 of 33 results.
of 2

ADD YOUR COMMENTS

Please note You must be a registered user of PulseToday and logged in to add comments. Opinions expressed below are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect those of PulseToday. Comments are considered in the public domain and may be used in future Pulse coverage. We accept no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for the accuracy or the content of member comments.

Comment*

You must be logged in to add a comment.Clickhere to login.

SIGN UP FOR EMAIL NEWSLETTERS

Keep up-to-date with the latest changes to the NHS, CPD and clinical guidelines. Sign up below or find out more.

POLL

Should GPs begin switching patients to atorvastatin immediately? Read the full story here

LATEST FORUM POSTS