This site is intended for health professionals only
Thursday 24 May 2012
Facebook Twiter Linkedin

Medical defence experts flag up ‘serious concerns’ over practice boundary pilots

By Andrew McNicoll | 06 Feb 2012

Exclusive: The Government's pilots trialling the abolition of practice boundaries will sow confusion over GP accountability for follow-up investigations and referrals, medical defence experts have warned.

The Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland (MDDUS) said the pilots – due to launch in London, Manchester and Nottingham in April – raised ‘serious concerns' over accountability and also continuity of care, particularly for patients with complex health needs.

Department of Health guidance issued last week said it was hoped patients in the pilots would ‘typically be working-age adults without complex health problems who are less likely to require home visits', but admitted PCT clusters needed to make arrangements for patients with complex care needs as part of the NHS ‘duty of care'.

Medico-legal advisers said GPs involved in the pilots needed a ‘clear agreement' on which practices are responsible for following up referrals and investigations, and that communications between practices in the pilots was vital.

Dr Barry Parker, MDDUS medical adviser, said: ‘Actions such as prescriptions of drugs, treatment plans and referrals must always be co-ordinated to avoid confusion, or duplication. Otherwise patients could inadvertently be prescribed medicines that interact with each other, or receive excessive supplies.'

Dr Richard  Vautrey, GPC deputy chair, said:  ‘There are clearly increased risks to patient safety if care becomes fragmented and this is one of the main reasons we've had so much concern about this policy.  We are encouraging the DH to take this issue seriously and put in place robust mechanisms to achieve this as part of this pilot.'

 

READERS' COMMENTS

George Farrelly, GP Partner,
06 Feb 2012
One by one, a bit at a time, the many problems with this policy will become evident. None of the three major political parties did any sort of risk assessment around this policy before championing it. Andy Burnham (in December 2011) persists in saying that he can 'see no reason' why this policy cannot just be implemented in full now, across the country. The Department of Health have done their best to avoid looking honestly at the risks (see the documentation accompanying the so-called 'consultation' in March 2010; it is a PR exercise to sell the policy), and have misled the English population and politicians. This is really quite shocking.

The Department of Health's 'guidance' on the commuters' pilot just tells the PCT clusters to sort it out: no details, just find a way to see the commuters who suddenly develop 'complex medical needs' at home (=get too sick to travel to work).

The people behind all this should be ashamed of themselves.
Average (0Votes)
Top
George Farrelly, GP Partner,
06 Feb 2012
Oh, I forgot to add: for further discussion and documentation, see my blog www.onegpprotest.org
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anonymous, PCT,
06 Feb 2012
Surley it will be the responsibility of the practice the patient is registered with. This change is not about making it possible to goto any GP any time a patient needs a consultation. Its about where the patient is registered. As a result I dont understand why this is any more complex than the current arrangements
Average (0Votes)
Top
Simon Ruffle, GP Partner,
06 Feb 2012
A point on boundaries:
Some complex patients move to accommodation nearby that's more suitable than there original home and want to stay with their GP. My experience of keeping these patients as they're 'nearby' just adds another 15-20 mins to the visit, makes it impossible to run to time or have lunch; if it's urgent and if in rush hour generates complaints from other patients and adds a safety issue to others. I'd suggest as in civil unrest, raising children and running a practice, boundaries are not only good but vital.
Average (0Votes)
Top

ADD YOUR COMMENTS

Please note You must be a registered user of PulseToday and logged in to add comments. Opinions expressed below are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect those of PulseToday. Comments are considered in the public domain and may be used in future Pulse coverage. We accept no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for the accuracy or the content of member comments.

Comment*

You must be logged in to add a comment.Clickhere to login.

SIGN UP FOR EMAIL NEWSLETTERS

Keep up-to-date with the latest changes to the NHS, CPD and clinical guidelines. Sign up below or find out more.

POLL

Will online booking ease the 8am rush?Read the full story here