This site is intended for health professionals only
Wednesday 23 May 2012
Facebook Twiter Linkedin

Funding squeeze forces practices to axe salaried GPs and staff

By Gareth Iacobucci | 11 Jan 2012

Exclusive GP practices across the country are being forced by unsustainable cost pressures to make reception staff, nurses and even salaried GPs redundant.

As many as one practice in five will lay off staff this year, with around a third of those having to shed a salaried GP post, a wide-ranging Pulse survey on workforce issues reveals.

The findings expose the toll taken on practices by financial pressures – as GPs prepare for a sixth pay squeeze in seven years – and the severity of the actions they are having to take.

The body representing medical accountants warned PMS practices were being hit particularly hard, with some forced to shed salaried GP posts to cover shortfalls in funding following contract reviews.

One GP in seven of 250 responding to the survey said they planned to make reception or administrative staff redundant, while others said they would be losing practice nurses, practice managers, specialist business managers and healthcare assistants. Of the two-thirds of GPs who said their practice employed salaried GPs, one in 10 said they would have to make at least one position redundant.

The GPC said the findings showed the extent of the strain being placed on practices, and called for more investment in primary care to protect services.

Bob Senior, chair of the Association of Independent Specialist Medical Accountants and director of medical services at RSM Tenon, said the situation was grave for many practices.

‘The practices I've seen who are actively making salaried doctors redundant are ones who've faced swingeing cuts in PMS funding.'

'I was with a practice this morning that had just had a PMS review carried out, and it is losing £130,000 over a three-year period,' he said.

Dr David Lloyd, a GP in Harrow, west London, said his practice would need to make five or six salaried GPs redundant at the polyclinic it runs and had already been forced to lay off nurses and administrative staff due to funding cuts.

He said: ‘It's a tragedy, but our PCT is £55m in the red so it slashed the budget. The philosophy was that patients should go and see their own GP, but this will put more strain on A&E – which will see patients at a much higher cost.'

Dr Jonathan Evans, a GP in Wrexham, north Wales, said his practice had been forced to shed staff and replace a nurse with a healthcare assistant.

‘Our health board is considering stopping enhanced services, which would cause losses to our practice of about £25,000, which we can't simply absorb,' he said.

‘We've failed to re-advertise posts that have gone through natural wastage. We have two further staff retiring in March and we will not be re-advertising.'

Dr Rahul Shah, a GP in Knebworth, Hertfordshire, said: ‘Partners here are having to do the admin work when previously we had staff working for us. We are at the bare minimum.'

GPC negotiator Dr Beth McCarron-Nash said it was time the Government reversed the downward pressure on GP funding: ‘Practices are now feeling the real strain as costs continue to rise and profits fall.'

‘We believe real benefits could be gained by investing much more in practice premises and development to enable us to improve care for our patients rather than having to cut back on staff or services.'

 

Editorial: GP job losses call for unity, not division

READERS' COMMENTS

Ben Sinclair, Sessional/Locum GP,
11 Jan 2012
My patients were shocked and upset when I told them I had been let go due to cuts. Many cried and I found it difficult to reassure them, explaining that it was just business and that I had been cut. Since I left I have continued to receive cards and letters of encouragement from patients and the practise.

I had been a long term locum on and off over the years, then a salaried GP 7 months at a mid-sized practise in York, when I was called into an unexpected meeting and told that I was to be made redundant due to financial difficulties. The practise had just built a beautiful new branch surgery which had overrun.

I had just become a father but I didn't take it personally as I knew that the partners must be in a tight corner to make Salarieds redundant and up till then I had been a long term locum so I know how to survive with no job security. The week after the other Salaried GP resigned to take a partnership elsewhere!

I decided after this poor experience of "job security" to take my destiny back in my own hands and have sidestepped into a Prison GP role, alongside private work, locuming and teaching medical students with some out of hours thrown in - at least this portfolio gives me more on my CV and has prospects for development, unlike salaried roles in many practises who have no intention of bringing up new partners.

There is no doubt that times are hard. Private work is drying up also but had been another income source over the last few years as I set up my own private health screening business https://www.optimiseclinic.co.uk/.

I probably won't commit to a permanent role exclusively in GP again until the current political fuss has calmed down abit (if ever it does) and until then the careers of many GPs who chose salaried work for good reasons will be destabilised by their partnered colleagues.

GP is increasingly about the business surviving at the end of the day and not the patient relationship or continuity. As ever this is an ongoing tension but the balance is shifting away from patients to survival for all doctors buried under a weight of bureucracy and penny pinching.
Average (11Votes)
Top
Simon Ruffle, GP Partner,
11 Jan 2012
For GPs income and thus practices to survive they must do work that is inappropriate to them. What with commissioning, the shift of secondary care to primary, revalidation, QoF and Qps- their health, education and ability to deal with their patients will all suffer.
GPs need to get hold of the real problems facing primary care which is the disintergration of the family doctor and local surgery, burgeoning workloads and increasing burocracy not just the pensions and income issues we all seem so focused on.
Good Luck Ben- no vacancies here I'm afraid
Average (4Votes)
Top
Ian Holliday, Other healthcare professional,
11 Jan 2012
I find this very worrying. I have my doubts whether the plans to move from hospital to community treatment will be accompanied by the financial resources. A new addition to the definition of "squeezed middle".
Average (2Votes)
Top
Brian Mansfield, GP Partner,
11 Jan 2012
The other side to face up to is which of the additional services we contract to do are generating profit . Any service must generate profit at base line operation to provide a safety margin if performance dips for any reason. The days of GPs providing additional services at cost or even out of the goodness of their hearts are gone. We must apply this rigourously to commissioning fora etc, i.e. pay + back fill or no can do!
Average (1Vote)
Top
Vinci Ho, GP Partner,
11 Jan 2012
The tall order of saving so many billions of pounds in NHS is Mission Difficult , it is Mission Impossible . Until some common sense is restored , patients and GPs (don't forget the cost of training doctors and hence GPs) will continue to suffer .
Average (1Vote)
Top
Vinci Ho, GP Partner,
11 Jan 2012
My correction ,
....saving so many billions of pounds is NOT Mission Difficult , it is Mission Impossible..
By the way , good luck , Ben
Life is about ups and downs , you never know what comes next....
Average (1Vote)
Top

ADD YOUR COMMENTS

Please note You must be a registered user of PulseToday and logged in to add comments. Opinions expressed below are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect those of PulseToday. Comments are considered in the public domain and may be used in future Pulse coverage. We accept no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for the accuracy or the content of member comments.

Comment*

You must be logged in to add a comment.Clickhere to login.

SIGN UP FOR EMAIL NEWSLETTERS

Keep up-to-date with the latest changes to the NHS, CPD and clinical guidelines. Sign up below or find out more.

POLL

Is self-care the answer to the NHS efficiency drive? Read the full story here